D'Andria Ursoleo Jacopo, Calì Cristiano, Losiggio Rosario, Limone Vito, Mucci Elena, Monaco Fabrizio
Department of Anesthesia and Intensive Care, IRCCS San Raffaele Scientific Institute, Milan, Italy.
Department of Philosophy and Educational Sciences, University of Turin, Turin, Italy.
J Palliat Med. 2025 Feb;28(2):265-279. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2024.0007. Epub 2024 Aug 2.
Spiritual care is an essential component of care for the terminally ill, because of its potential to positively impact patient perception of quality of life and dignity. However, it continues to be the least cultivated or even most overlooked aspect of palliative care and end of life. We performed a methodological review using bibliometric analysis to provide a holistic view of the scientific output published on this topic in the literature at the same time outlining present perspectives and research trends. In accordance with the BIBLIO checklist for reporting the bibliometric reviews of the biomedical literature, pertinent articles were retrieved from the Web of Science (WOS) database. The search string included "spiritual care," "end of life," and their synonyms. The VOSviewer (version 1.6.17) software was used to conduct comprehensive analyses. Semantic and research networks, bibliographic coupling, and journal analysis were examined. A total of 924 articles were identified in WOS, and 842 were retrieved. An increasing trend in the number of publications is observed from 1981 to date, with a peak in the 2019-2021 timeframe. Most articles focused on palliative care, spirituality, spiritual care, religion, end of life, and cancer. The contributed the highest number of published documents, while the was the top-cited journal. The highest number of publications originated from collaborations of authors from the United Kingdom, the United States, and Australia. The remarkable increase in the number of publications on spiritual care observed in the years of the COVID-19 pandemic likely reflected global concerns, reasserting the importance of prioritizing spiritual care for whole-person palliation. Spiritual care is integrated with palliative care, in line with the latter's holistic nature and the recognition of spirituality as a fundamental aspect of end-of-life care. Nurses and chaplains exhibited more involvement in palliative-spiritual care than physicians reflecting the belief that chaplains are perceived as specialized providers, and nurses, owing to their direct exposure to spiritual suffering and ethos, are deemed suitable for providing spiritual care.
精神关怀是临终关怀的重要组成部分,因为它有可能对患者对生活质量和尊严的认知产生积极影响。然而,它仍然是姑息治疗和生命末期护理中最缺乏培养甚至最被忽视的方面。我们使用文献计量分析进行了一项方法学综述,以全面了解该主题在文献中发表的科学成果,同时概述当前的观点和研究趋势。根据报告生物医学文献计量综述的BIBLIO清单,从科学网(WOS)数据库中检索相关文章。搜索词包括“精神关怀”、“生命末期”及其同义词。使用VOSviewer(1.6.17版)软件进行综合分析。检查了语义和研究网络、文献耦合和期刊分析。在WOS中总共识别出924篇文章,检索到842篇。从1981年至今,出版物数量呈上升趋势,在2019 - 2021年期间达到峰值。大多数文章关注姑息治疗、灵性、精神关怀、宗教、生命末期和癌症。[此处可能有信息缺失,原文中两个空处未明确内容]贡献了最多的已发表文献数量,而[此处可能有信息缺失,原文中未明确具体期刊名称]是被引用次数最多的期刊。出版物数量最多的来自英国、美国和澳大利亚作者的合作。在新冠疫情期间观察到的精神关怀出版物数量的显著增加,可能反映了全球的关注,再次强调了将精神关怀作为全人姑息治疗优先事项的重要性。精神关怀与姑息治疗相结合,这符合后者的整体性质以及将灵性视为生命末期护理基本方面的认识。护士和牧师在姑息 - 精神关怀方面比医生表现出更多的参与,这反映了一种观念,即牧师被视为专业提供者,而护士由于直接接触精神痛苦和精神特质,被认为适合提供精神关怀。