Fernandes Martins Kairo, Teixeira Denilson
Federal University of Goiás (UFG), Brazil.
National Institute of Metrology, Quality and Technology (INMETRO), Brazil.
Heliyon. 2024 Jul 6;10(14):e34157. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e34157. eCollection 2024 Jul 30.
The diversity of sustainable certifications raises questions about the credibility, intentions, and impacts of Voluntary Sustainability Standards (VSS) on Global Value Chains (GVC). Few studies show the impacts of VSS on different sustainable dimensions in sectors such as the non-timber forest product (NTFP) sector. This paper aims to investigate in the value chain of the most important NTFP in the Amazon, açaí, whether VSS contributes to sustainable outcomes in the Governance, Environmental, Economic, and Social dimensions. Using case studies in enterprises of the açaí chain and the use of tools and indicators was possible to generate information that is currently scarce for NTFPs in the Amazon from the VSS perspective. The results show that there is a great distance that the weakest links of the GVC (Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises - MSMEs) must walk to adopt VSS and be inserted into the global market. The requirements are based on bureaucratic management activities, which are extraordinarily complex and involve many issues and indicators. The VSS lacks supplements that evaluate and validate the results reported by the companies as sustainable. Finally, the VSS is still far from ensuring an inclusive and fully sustainable chain by itself.
可持续认证的多样性引发了人们对自愿性可持续标准(VSS)在全球价值链(GVC)中的可信度、意图和影响的质疑。很少有研究表明VSS对非木材林产品(NTFP)等部门不同可持续维度的影响。本文旨在调查亚马逊地区最重要的非木材林产品——阿萨伊果的价值链中,VSS是否在治理、环境、经济和社会维度上有助于实现可持续成果。通过对阿萨伊果产业链上企业的案例研究以及工具和指标的使用,从VSS角度生成了目前亚马逊地区非木材林产品稀缺的信息。结果表明,全球价值链的最薄弱环节(微型、小型和中型企业——MSMEs)在采用VSS并融入全球市场方面还有很长的路要走。这些要求基于官僚主义管理活动,极其复杂且涉及许多问题和指标。VSS缺乏对公司报告为可持续的结果进行评估和验证的补充措施。最后,VSS本身仍远未确保形成一个包容且完全可持续的产业链。