Pollard Samantha, Ehman Morgan, Hermansen Anna, Weymann Deirdre, Krebs Emanuel, Ho Cheryl, Lim Howard J, Jones Steven, Bombard Yvonne, Hanna Timothy P, Hessels Chiquita, Longstaff Holly, Cook-Deegan Robert, Bubela Tania, Regier Dean A
Cancer Control Research, BC Cancer Research Institute, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
Faculty of Health Sciences, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, BC, Canada.
JCO Precis Oncol. 2024 Aug;8:e2400184. doi: 10.1200/PO.24.00184.
In Canada, health data are siloed, slowing bioinnovation and evidence generation for personalized cancer care. Secured data-sharing platforms (SDSPs) can enable data analysis across silos through rapid concatenation across trial and real-world settings and timely researcher access. To motivate patient participation and trust in research, it is critical to ensure that SDSP design and oversight align with patients' values and address their concerns. We sought to qualitatively characterize patient preferences for the design of a pan-Canadian SDSP.
Between January 2022 and July 2023, we conducted pan-Canadian virtual focus groups with individuals who had a personal history of cancer. Following each focus group, participants were invited to provide feedback on early-phase analysis results via a member-checking survey. Three trained qualitative researchers analyzed data using thematic analysis.
Twenty-eight individuals participated across five focus groups. Four focus groups were conducted in English and one in French. Thematic analysis generated two major and five minor themes. Analytic themes spanned personal and population implications of data sharing and willingness to manage perceived risks. Participants were supportive of increasing access to health data for precision oncology research, while voicing concerns about unintended data use, reidentification, and inequitable access to costly therapeutics. To mitigate perceived risks, participants highlighted the value of data access oversight and governance and informational transparency.
Strategies for secured data sharing should anticipate and mitigate the risks that patients perceive. Participants supported enhancing timely research capability while ensuring safeguards to protect patient autonomy and privacy. Our study informs the development of data-governance and data-sharing frameworks that integrate real-world and trial data, informed by evidence from direct patient input.
在加拿大,健康数据分散存储,减缓了生物创新以及个性化癌症护理的证据生成。安全数据共享平台(SDSPs)能够通过跨试验和真实世界环境的快速整合以及研究人员的及时访问,实现跨部门的数据分析。为了激发患者参与研究并建立信任,确保SDSP的设计和监督符合患者价值观并解决他们的担忧至关重要。我们试图定性描述患者对泛加拿大SDSP设计的偏好。
在2022年1月至2023年7月期间,我们与有个人癌症病史的个体进行了泛加拿大虚拟焦点小组讨论。在每个焦点小组讨论之后,邀请参与者通过成员核对调查对早期分析结果提供反馈。三名经过培训的定性研究人员使用主题分析法对数据进行分析。
28人参与了五个焦点小组讨论。四个焦点小组用英语进行,一个用法语进行。主题分析产生了两个主要主题和五个次要主题。分析主题涵盖了数据共享对个人和人群的影响以及管理感知风险的意愿。参与者支持增加获取健康数据以用于精准肿瘤学研究,同时对数据的意外使用、重新识别以及昂贵治疗药物的不公平获取表示担忧。为了降低感知风险,参与者强调了数据访问监督、治理和信息透明度的价值。
安全数据共享策略应预见并减轻患者感知到的风险。参与者支持提高及时研究能力,同时确保保护患者自主权和隐私的保障措施。我们的研究为数据治理和数据共享框架的开发提供了信息,这些框架整合了真实世界和试验数据,并以直接患者输入的证据为依据。