Patterson Christopher, Roberts Michelle, Yousiph Taylor, Robson Georgia, Lewer Kelly, Jay Elissa-Kate, Moxham Lorna
Faculty of Science, Medicine and Health, University of Wollongong, Wollongong, New South Wales, Australia.
J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs. 2025 Feb;32(1):143-151. doi: 10.1111/jpm.13093. Epub 2024 Aug 8.
Pre-registration nursing students report high rates of stigma, leading to low help-seeking attitudes when seeking help for mental health issues. Traditional mental health clinical placements can improve stigma related to attitudes and social distance for pre-registration nursing students.
There are nil recorded clinical placement interventions that have decreased self-stigma for pre-registration nursing students, with this study highlighting a clinical placement model that is effective in significantly decreasing self-stigma.
The knowledge around the mental health struggles experienced by pre-registration nursing students, and the effect of a non-traditional mental health placement in decreasing self-stigmatizing attitudes in this population, is important for the future of retaining mental health nurses. There is an opportunity to use the clinical placement model presented, and design interventions for nursing students that aims to promote help-seeking behaviours.
INTRODUCTION: Traditional mental health clinical placements can improve pre-registration nurse stigma toward mental illness, particularly in measures of attitudes and social distance. However, they have not yet been shown to improve self-stigma, which affects mental health disclosure and help-seeking behaviour.
The present study investigates nursing students' stigma following a non-traditional mental health placement immersed alongside people living with mental illness.
Three stigma subtypes were measured using the Opening Minds Scale for Healthcare Providers: Attitudes, Social Distance, and Disclosure/Help-seeking.
Pre-registration nurses (N = 848) completed the instrument pre- and post-placement. A multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) identified a large effect of placement on stigma (p < .001, = .101). Post hoc pairwise comparisons revealed all three types of stigma decreased after the non-traditional placement (Attitudes: p < .001, = 0.09, Social Distance: p < .001, = 0.07, Disclosure/Help-seeking: p < .001, = 0.04).
These findings emphasize that attending a non-traditional mental health clinical placement can effectively reduce multiple types of nursing student stigma.
Further research in this area could focus on which attributes of the clinical placement setting foster positive help-seeking.
These results are noteworthy for stigma surrounding disclosure/help-seeking, as traditional (i.e. hospital-based) mental-health clinical placements have been found ineffective in reducing nursing student stigma in this domain.
Further research into the effectiveness of non-traditional clinical placements in reducing nursing students' stigma regarding mental health disclosure and help-seeking, is required.
预注册护理专业学生报告称遭受耻辱感的比例很高,这导致他们在寻求心理健康问题帮助时求助态度较低。传统的心理健康临床实习可以改善预注册护理专业学生在态度和社会距离方面与耻辱感相关的问题。
没有记录表明临床实习干预措施能降低预注册护理专业学生的自我耻辱感,而本研究突出了一种能有效显著降低自我耻辱感的临床实习模式。
了解预注册护理专业学生所经历的心理健康困扰,以及非传统心理健康实习对减少该群体自我耻辱态度的影响,对未来留住心理健康护士至关重要。有机会采用所提出的临床实习模式,并为护理专业学生设计旨在促进求助行为的干预措施。
引言:传统的心理健康临床实习可以改善预注册护士对精神疾病的耻辱感,特别是在态度和社会距离方面的衡量指标。然而,尚未证明它们能改善自我耻辱感,而自我耻辱感会影响心理健康问题的披露和求助行为。
本研究调查了护理专业学生在与精神疾病患者一起参与非传统心理健康实习后的耻辱感。
使用《医疗服务提供者开放心态量表》测量三种耻辱感亚型:态度、社会距离和披露/求助。
预注册护士(N = 848)在实习前后完成了该量表。多变量方差分析(MANOVA)确定实习对耻辱感有很大影响(p <.001,η² =.101)。事后成对比较显示,在非传统实习后,所有三种耻辱感类型都有所下降(态度:p <.001,η² = 0.09;社会距离:p <.001,η² = 0.07;披露/求助:p <.001,η² = 0.04)。
这些发现强调,参加非传统心理健康临床实习可以有效减少多种类型的护理专业学生耻辱感。
该领域的进一步研究可以关注临床实习环境的哪些属性促进了积极的求助行为。
这些结果对于围绕披露/求助的耻辱感而言值得关注,因为传统的(即基于医院的)心理健康临床实习在减少该领域护理专业学生耻辱感方面已被证明无效。
需要进一步研究非传统临床实习在减少护理专业学生对心理健康披露和求助的耻辱感方面的有效性。