Centre for Hate Studies, University of Leicester, UK.
J Interpers Violence. 2024 Sep;39(17-18):3904-3931. doi: 10.1177/08862605241260004.
It is well-established within the hate studies literature that the majority of hate crimes and incidents of targeted hostility are perpetrated by those in the "majority" society. In the UK, academic and official research consistently shows that young White, British males are most commonly the culprits of all forms of targeted victimization, especially racist hate. However, urban areas of "super-diversity" offer researchers an opportunity to understand hate crime victimization and perpetration in a more nuanced and comprehensive way. Hate studies research has slowly begun to highlight instances of people from marginalized and stigmatized groups being targeted on the basis of their identity by individuals who are also members of minority groups, sometimes even the same minority group as the victim. Very little is understood about this particular victimizing dynamic other than it appears to be an attempt by minority group members to "fit in" by adopting what they perceive to be majority group values and attitudes. By drawing from 44 qualitative in-depth interviews exploring the experiences of new migrants and refugees and observations from 20 months of grassroots engagement, this article challenges established theories of "othering" that overwhelmingly refer to binary, static majority/minority tensions. The stories of these too-often "hidden" victims of targeted hostility offer a fresh perspective on the relationships between victims of hate and perpetrators. The article also contributes new explanations as to why those who are often targeted go on to target others.
在仇恨研究文献中,人们早已认识到,大多数仇恨犯罪和有针对性的敌意事件都是由“多数”社会中的人所为。在英国,学术和官方研究一直表明,年轻的白人英国男性最常成为各种有针对性的受害行为,尤其是种族仇恨的罪魁祸首。然而,“超级多元化”的城市地区为研究人员提供了一个以更细致和全面的方式理解仇恨犯罪受害和犯罪的机会。仇恨研究的缓慢发展开始强调这样的实例,即处于边缘和污名化群体的人,由于其身份,而成为来自少数群体的个人的目标,有时甚至是受害者所在的同一少数群体。除了少数群体成员试图通过采用他们认为是多数群体的价值观和态度来“融入”之外,对于这种特殊的加害动态,人们知之甚少。本文通过 44 次深入的定性访谈,探讨了新移民和难民的经历,并结合 20 个月的基层参与观察,挑战了关于“他者化”的既定理论,这些理论压倒性地指的是二元、静态的多数/少数群体紧张关系。这些常常被“隐藏”的有针对性敌意受害者的故事为仇恨受害者和加害者之间的关系提供了一个新的视角。本文还对那些经常成为目标的人为何会转而针对他人做出新的解释。