Cano Neus, Gómez-Hernández Josep, Ariza Mar, Mora Toni, Roche David, Porras-Garcia Bruno, Garolera Maite
Brain, Cognition and Behavior Research Group, Consorci Sanitari de Terrassa (CST), Terrassa, Spain.
BrainXRLab, Department of Psychology, Universitat Internacional de Catalunya, Sant Cugat, Spain.
Front Psychol. 2024 Jul 25;15:1441018. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1441018. eCollection 2024.
Adults with Post-COVID-19 Condition (PCC) may show cognitive impairments in attention, processing speed, memory, and executive function. Multimodal programs that combine cognitive training, physical activity and emotional tasks, such as mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs), may offer a suitable alternative for improving PCC treatments. Immersive Virtual Reality (IVR) is a promising technology that can enhance traditional cognitive training, physical activity, and MBIs. The use of IVR technology may increase engagement with these interventions and potentially enhance the individual benefits of cognitive training, exercise and MBIs. The current study evaluated the impact of a multimodal IVR intervention, comparing this with a usual care intervention (control group), in order to assess changes in cognition and mental health in adults with PCC. We also aimed to assess user experience factors such as enjoyment, perceived improvement, and fatigue following each multimodal IVR session within the experimental group.
Thirty-one participants with PCC symptoms were assigned to either the experimental group (IVR, = 15) or the control group (usual care intervention, = 16) in a quasi-experimental design study. The multimodal IVR intervention consisted of MBI, cognitive training and physical exercise and was delivered in a 60-min group session with 5 participants, twice a week, for 8 weeks (16 sessions in total). Measures of global cognition, attention, processing speed, verbal episodic memory and subjective memory complaints (primary measures), and depressive and anxiety symptoms and fatigue (secondary measures) were assessed at baseline and also after 8 weeks (post-intervention).
Mixed between-group (group) and within-group (pre-post assessments) ANOVAs revealed significant grouptime interactions in global cognition, simple attention, processing speed, memory and depressive symptoms, with large effect sizes ( < 0.05; partial η > 0.14). There was also a marginally significant grouptime interaction for executive function ( = 0.05). Follow-up analyses comparing pre-and post-intervention outcomes for each group separately showed that the experimental group significantly improved in global cognition, processing speed, memory and depressive symptoms, while the control group showed no significant pre-post changes. Friedman tests showed a significant main effect of time (χ(2) = 6.609, = 0.04), with a gradual increase in enjoyment from the first, to the mid, and then to the final session. In addition, perceived improvement scores remained high throughout the intervention, and patient-reported fatigue levels did not fluctuate significantly throughout the intervention.
To our knowledge, no previous research has combined cognitive training, physical exercise and MBI using an IVR paradigm in adults with PCC. Despite their inherent limitations, our findings mark a pioneering step toward improving cognition and mental health outcomes in PCC through the innovative use of new technology and multimodal approaches. This first study should be accompanied by more extensive, randomized clinical trials aimed at further exploring and refining these interventions.
患有新冠后状况(PCC)的成年人可能在注意力、处理速度、记忆和执行功能方面表现出认知障碍。结合认知训练、体育活动和情感任务的多模式项目,如基于正念的干预措施(MBIs),可能为改善PCC治疗提供合适的替代方案。沉浸式虚拟现实(IVR)是一种有前景的技术,可以增强传统的认知训练、体育活动和MBIs。IVR技术的使用可能会增加对这些干预措施的参与度,并有可能增强认知训练、锻炼和MBIs的个体效益。本研究评估了多模式IVR干预的影响,并将其与常规护理干预(对照组)进行比较,以评估患有PCC的成年人在认知和心理健康方面的变化。我们还旨在评估实验组中每次多模式IVR课程后的用户体验因素,如愉悦感、感知改善和疲劳感。
在一项准实验设计研究中,31名有PCC症状的参与者被分配到实验组(IVR,n = 15)或对照组(常规护理干预,n = 16)。多模式IVR干预包括MBI、认知训练和体育锻炼,以60分钟的小组课程形式进行,每组5名参与者,每周两次,共8周(总共16次课程)。在基线和8周后(干预后)评估整体认知、注意力、处理速度、言语情景记忆和主观记忆抱怨(主要指标),以及抑郁和焦虑症状及疲劳(次要指标)。
组间(组)和组内(前后评估)混合方差分析显示,在整体认知、简单注意力、处理速度、记忆和抑郁症状方面存在显著的组时间交互作用,效应量较大(p < 0.05;偏η² > 0.14)。执行功能方面也存在边缘显著的组时间交互作用(p = 0.05)。分别比较每组干预前后结果的后续分析表明,实验组在整体认知、处理速度、记忆和抑郁症状方面有显著改善,而对照组在干预前后没有显著变化。弗里德曼检验显示时间有显著的主效应(χ(2) = 6.609,p = 0.04),愉悦感从第一次课程到中间课程再到最后课程逐渐增加。此外,在整个干预过程中,感知改善得分一直很高,患者报告的疲劳水平在整个干预过程中没有显著波动。
据我们所知,以前没有研究在患有PCC的成年人中使用IVR范式将认知训练、体育锻炼和MBI结合起来。尽管存在固有的局限性,但我们的研究结果标志着通过创新使用新技术和多模式方法朝着改善PCC的认知和心理健康结果迈出了开创性的一步。这项首次研究应该伴随着更广泛的随机临床试验,旨在进一步探索和完善这些干预措施。