Baugh Abigail, Reiser Victoria, Zhao Jian, Klein Sara Jo, Rosenzweig Margaret Quinn
From University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
University of Pittsburgh School of Nursing, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
J Adv Pract Oncol. 2024 Mar;15(2):95-101. doi: 10.6004/jadpro.2024.15.2.2. Epub 2024 Mar 1.
Occupational exhaustion, or burnout, is characterized with three components: emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and sense of decreased personal accomplishment. Advanced practice providers (APPs) in oncology care are at particular risk for burnout.
This was a prospective, comparative, descriptive study utilizing a convenience sample of oncology APPs who completed the Advanced Practice Provider Oncology Web Education Resource (AP-POWER; formerly Oncology Nurse Practitioner Web Education Resource, or ONc-PoWER), developed to provide educational content for new oncology APPs. The study purpose was to utilize the AP-POWER alumni to describe the level of burnout (Maslach Burnout Inventory) as well as resilience (Brief Resilience Scale) after at least 1 year in oncology practice, and to compare these scores according to the number of APP oncology practice years.
Of the 133 questionnaires emailed, 30 were returned (22.6% response) and 27 completed (20.3%). Within the Maslach Burnout Inventory, the mean score of the emotional exhaustion subscale was 25.19 (standard deviation [SD] 12.74; high degree of occupational exhaustion), depersonalization 7.74 (SD 5.98; moderate degree), and personal achievement 31.85 (SD 6.20; low degree). The resilience scores had a mean of 22.52 (SD 3.37; normal range). Resiliency was positively associated with personal accomplishment. There was no difference in burnout among newer (< 3 years) and more experienced (> 3 years) oncology APPs.
Oncology APPs report key indications of burnout, including a high degree of emotional exhaustion and moderate depersonalization, which was not mitigated through resiliency.
CONCLUSIONS/IMPLICATIONS: The results are worrisome. Burnout scores for oncology APPs are high. Resiliency is present but is not protective for burnout. Strategies must be developed institutionally to support these key cancer care providers.
职业倦怠,或曰工作耗竭,具有三个特征:情感耗竭、去人格化和个人成就感降低。肿瘤护理领域的高级执业人员(APP)尤其面临职业倦怠的风险。
这是一项前瞻性、比较性、描述性研究,采用便利抽样法选取了完成高级执业人员肿瘤网络教育资源(AP-POWER;原肿瘤护理执业人员网络教育资源,即ONc-PoWER)的肿瘤APP,该资源旨在为新入职的肿瘤APP提供教育内容。研究目的是利用AP-POWER的校友来描述肿瘤实践至少1年后的职业倦怠水平(马氏职业倦怠量表)以及心理弹性(简易心理弹性量表),并根据APP肿瘤实践年限比较这些得分。
在通过电子邮件发送的133份问卷中,30份被退回(回复率22.6%),27份完整填写(回复率20.3%)。在马氏职业倦怠量表中,情感耗竭子量表的平均得分为25.19(标准差[SD]12.74;高度职业倦怠),去人格化7.74(SD 5.98;中度),个人成就感31.85(SD 6.20;低度)。心理弹性得分平均为22.52(SD 3.37;正常范围)。心理弹性与个人成就感呈正相关。新入职(<3年)和经验更丰富(>3年)的肿瘤APP在职业倦怠方面没有差异。
肿瘤APP报告了职业倦怠的关键指标,包括高度的情感耗竭和中度的去人格化,心理弹性并未缓解这种情况。
结论/启示:结果令人担忧。肿瘤APP的职业倦怠得分很高。心理弹性存在,但对职业倦怠没有保护作用。必须在机构层面制定策略来支持这些关键的癌症护理提供者。