Perez Velazquez Jose Luis, Mateos Diego Martin, Guevara Ramon, Wennberg Richard
The Ronin Institute, Montclair, NJ, United States.
Institute for Globally Distributed Open Research and Education, Gothenburg, Sweden.
Front Syst Neurosci. 2024 Jul 29;18:1426986. doi: 10.3389/fnsys.2024.1426986. eCollection 2024.
There is such a vast proliferation of scientific theories of consciousness that it is worrying some scholars. There are even competitions to test different theories, and the results are inconclusive. Consciousness research, far from converging toward a unifying framework, is becoming more discordant than ever, especially with respect to theoretical elements that do not have a clear neurobiological basis. Rather than dueling theories, an integration across theories is needed to facilitate a comprehensive view on consciousness and on how normal nervous system dynamics can develop into pathological states. In dealing with what is considered an extremely complex matter, we try to adopt a perspective from which the subject appears in relative simplicity. Grounded in experimental and theoretical observations, we advance an encompassing biophysical theory, MaxCon, which incorporates aspects of several of the main existing neuroscientific consciousness theories, finding convergence points in an attempt to simplify and to understand how cellular collective activity is organized to fulfill the dynamic requirements of the diverse theories our proposal comprises. Moreover, a computable index indicating consciousness level is presented. Derived from the level of description of the interactions among cell networks, our proposal highlights the association of consciousness with maximization of the number of configurations of neural network connections -constrained by neuroanatomy, biophysics and the environment- that is common to all consciousness theories.
意识的科学理论大量涌现,这让一些学者感到担忧。甚至还有测试不同理论的竞赛,但其结果尚无定论。意识研究远未趋向于一个统一的框架,反而比以往任何时候都更加不一致,尤其是在那些没有明确神经生物学基础的理论元素方面。我们需要的不是理论之间的对决,而是跨理论的整合,以便对意识以及正常神经系统动态如何发展为病理状态形成全面的认识。在处理这个被认为极其复杂的问题时,我们试图采用一种视角,使这个主题呈现出相对的简单性。基于实验和理论观察,我们提出了一个全面的生物物理理论——最大连接理论(MaxCon),它融合了几种主要现有神经科学意识理论的各个方面,寻找汇聚点,试图简化并理解细胞集体活动是如何组织起来以满足我们的提议所包含的各种理论的动态需求的。此外,还提出了一个表示意识水平的可计算指标。我们的提议源自对细胞网络间相互作用的描述层次,它突出了意识与神经网络连接配置数量最大化之间的关联——这种最大化受到神经解剖学、生物物理学和环境的限制——这是所有意识理论的共同之处。