Ameen Khadijah, Airhihenbuwa Collins
Georgia State University, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Health Promot Pract. 2024 Aug 13:15248399241269996. doi: 10.1177/15248399241269996.
A bystander to racial violence is conventionally thought of as someone who witnesses an overt act of racial oppression at the interpersonal level, such as police brutality. However, racial violence in health research, pedagogy, and practice often shows up more covertly, like through epistemic injustice, deficits-based framing, and racial essentialism. We aim to expand how we think about bystanders and perpetrators of racial violence within health institutions, and how antiracism bystander behavioral approaches can be deployed to intervene against such violence. Existing public health antiracism frameworks, such as the Public Health Critical Race Praxis and the PEN-3 Cultural Model, offer valuable constructs and processes through which health practitioners, researchers, and academics can disrupt racial violence. Such antiracism frameworks are well suited to provide individuals within public health and health care with the knowledge, skills, and efficacy to intervene as engaged bystanders against racism within their contexts. To illustrate how constructs within antiracism frameworks can be applied by bystanders in various health settings, we outline case examples of antiracism bystander interventions across three scenarios. The more bystanders there are within health institutions that are equipped with antiracism tools, the more likely normative behaviors uplifting White supremacy within these institutions can be disrupted and health equity can be actualized.
传统上,种族暴力的旁观者被认为是在人际层面目睹公开的种族压迫行为的人,比如警察暴行。然而,健康研究、教学和实践中的种族暴力往往更为隐蔽,例如通过认知不公正、基于缺陷的框架构建和种族本质主义表现出来。我们旨在拓展对医疗机构中种族暴力旁观者和实施者的思考方式,以及如何运用反种族主义旁观者行为方法来干预此类暴力。现有的公共卫生反种族主义框架,如公共卫生批判种族实践和 PEN - 3 文化模型,提供了有价值的架构和流程,健康从业者、研究人员和学者可借此扰乱种族暴力。此类反种族主义框架非常适合为公共卫生和医疗保健领域的个人提供知识、技能和效能,使其能够作为积极的旁观者在自身环境中干预种族主义。为说明反种族主义框架中的架构如何被不同健康环境中的旁观者应用,我们概述了三种场景下反种族主义旁观者干预的案例。医疗机构中配备反种族主义工具的旁观者越多,这些机构内助长白人至上主义的规范行为就越有可能被扰乱,健康公平也就越有可能实现。