Cox Thomas, Columbus Cristie, Ahmed Kashif, Higginbotham Julie
Faculty Development and Research Education, Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA.
Department of Medical Education, Baylor University Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, USA.
Proc (Bayl Univ Med Cent). 2024 Jul 8;37(5):884-887. doi: 10.1080/08998280.2024.2371766. eCollection 2024.
The success of a journal club hinges on the presentation of articles that are both relevant and scientifically robust. It's insufficient for presenters to merely read through an article and highlight a few points without a clear focus. A strong presentation should thoroughly describe the relevance and validity of the study, offer a critique, suggest how further research might address the issue, and discuss the implications for patient care. Selecting the right article is crucial. It is recommended to begin the presentation with a case scenario to emphasize the article's clinical relevance and to revisit the case at the conclusion of the presentation. The components of the article presentation should include background information, methodology and results, and the authors' discussion. Additionally, the presenter should critique the article's validity, noting any potential biases, evaluating the risks and costs of the proposed intervention, and assessing how well the article supports its hypothesis. The presentation should conclude with a summary statement that includes conclusions, implications, and future directions. Having a structured process for journal club presentations guides presenters and ensures that attendees derive maximum benefit from the educational activity. This organized approach fosters a deeper understanding and encourages critical thinking among participants.
期刊俱乐部的成功取决于所展示文章的相关性和科学稳健性。仅仅通读一篇文章并随意强调几点而没有清晰重点,对展示者来说是不够的。一个有力的展示应该全面描述研究的相关性和有效性,进行批判性分析,提出进一步研究如何解决该问题的建议,并讨论对患者护理的影响。选择合适的文章至关重要。建议在展示开始时引入一个病例场景,以强调文章的临床相关性,并在展示结束时回顾该病例。文章展示的组成部分应包括背景信息、方法和结果,以及作者的讨论。此外,展示者应评判文章的有效性,指出任何潜在的偏差,评估所提议干预措施的风险和成本,并评估文章对其假设的支持程度。展示应以总结陈述结束,包括结论、影响和未来方向。为期刊俱乐部展示制定一个结构化流程可以指导展示者,并确保参与者从这项教育活动中获得最大收益。这种有条理的方法能促进更深入的理解,并鼓励参与者进行批判性思考。