Rae Sarah, Pullenayegum Eleanor, Ong Frank, Dennis Cindy-Lee, Hamilton Jill, Maguire Jonathon, Birken Catherine
Child Health Evaluative Sciences, The Peter Gilgan Centre for Research and Learning, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Nutritional Sciences, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Child Obes. 2025 Jan;21(1):39-49. doi: 10.1089/chi.2023.0065. Epub 2024 Aug 22.
The purpose of this study was to determine the reliability of anthropometric measurements between two trained anthropometrists working in a team and one trained anthropometrist working with a child's parent/caregiver in a primary health care setting. An observational study to determine measurement reliability was conducted in a primary care child research network in Canada. In total, 120 children 0-5 years old had their anthropometric measurement taken twice by two trained anthropometrists working in a team and twice by one trained anthropometrist working with a child's parent/caregiver. Inter- and intra-observer reliability was calculated using the technical error of measurement (TEM), relative TEM (%TEM), and the coefficient of reliability (R). The %TEM values for length/height and weight were <2%, and the R coefficient values were >0.99, indicating a high degree of inter- and intra-observer reliability. The TEM values demonstrated a high degree of reliability for inter- and intra-observer measurement of length/height in comparison with other anthropometric measurement parameters. However, there was greater variation seen in the length measurement for children 0 to <2 years of age and in arm circumference measurement across both age-groups. This study suggests that anthropometric measurement taken by one trained anthropometrist with the assistance of a parent/caregiver is reliable. These findings provide evidence to support inclusion of a child's parent/caregiver with anthropometric measurement collection in clinical setting(s) to enhance feasibility and efficiency and reduce the research costs of including a second trained anthropometrist.
本研究的目的是确定在团队中工作的两名经过培训的人体测量师之间以及在初级卫生保健环境中与儿童的父母/照顾者一起工作的一名经过培训的人体测量师进行人体测量的可靠性。在加拿大的一个初级保健儿童研究网络中进行了一项确定测量可靠性的观察性研究。总共120名0至5岁的儿童由两名在团队中工作的经过培训的人体测量师测量了两次人体测量数据,以及由一名与儿童的父母/照顾者一起工作的经过培训的人体测量师测量了两次。使用测量技术误差(TEM)、相对TEM(%TEM)和可靠性系数(R)计算观察者间和观察者内的可靠性。长度/身高和体重的%TEM值<2%,R系数值>0.99,表明观察者间和观察者内的可靠性程度很高。与其他人体测量参数相比,TEM值表明观察者间和观察者内对长度/身高测量具有高度可靠性。然而,在0至<2岁儿童的长度测量以及两个年龄组的臂围测量中观察到更大的差异。本研究表明,一名经过培训的人体测量师在父母/照顾者的协助下进行的人体测量是可靠的。这些发现为支持在临床环境中让儿童的父母/照顾者参与人体测量数据收集提供了证据,以提高可行性和效率,并降低纳入第二名经过培训的人体测量师的研究成本。