Silber Michael H, Block Darci R, St Louis Erik K
Center for Sleep Medicine, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine and Science, Rochester, Minnesota.
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine and Science, Rochester, Minnesota.
J Clin Sleep Med. 2025 Jan 1;21(1):65-67. doi: 10.5664/jcsm.11332.
Serum ferritin levels are used to determine the need for iron supplementation in patients with restless legs syndrome. The purpose of this study was to determine whether immunoassay measurement of serum ferritin yields varying levels according to different manufacturers' assays, with resultant variation in cutoff values.
We compared serum ferritin levels using 116 clinical samples assessed by the Beckman and Roche methods.
Although there was a high correlation between results obtained from the 2 methods (R = 0.99), the absolute values differed. The equivalent ferritin measures determined by the Beckman and Roche methods were 50 μg/dl, 83 μg/dl; 75 μg/dl, 121 μg/dl; 100 μg/dl, 158 μg/dl; and 300 μg/dl, 457 μg/dl.
It is uncertain which assays were used to measure serum ferritin in the seminal studies on which current guidelines for iron therapy for restless legs syndrome are based. In view of this uncertainty, as well as the limited data on which current recommendations are based, clinicians should be flexible in using recommended serum ferritin cutoff values, also using percentage of transferrin saturation. Assuming that Beckman or equivalent assays were used, centers using the Roche method need to adjust the cutoffs for administration of oral iron and intravenous iron recommended by current practice guidelines to avoid withholding treatment for restless legs syndrome patients who might benefit from iron supplementation.
Silber MH, Block DR, St. Louis EK. Serum ferritin measurements differ according to the assay used: implications for iron therapy in restless legs syndrome. 2025;21(1):65-67.
血清铁蛋白水平用于确定不安腿综合征患者是否需要补充铁剂。本研究的目的是确定血清铁蛋白的免疫测定法是否会因不同厂家的检测方法而产生不同水平的结果,从而导致临界值的变化。
我们使用贝克曼法和罗氏法对116份临床样本的血清铁蛋白水平进行了比较。
虽然两种方法得到的结果之间存在高度相关性(R = 0.99),但绝对值不同。贝克曼法和罗氏法测定的等效铁蛋白量分别为50μg/dl、83μg/dl;75μg/dl、121μg/dl;100μg/dl、158μg/dl;300μg/dl、457μg/dl。
目前不安腿综合征铁治疗指南所依据的开创性研究中,不确定使用了哪种检测方法来测量血清铁蛋白。鉴于这种不确定性,以及当前建议所依据的数据有限,临床医生在使用推荐的血清铁蛋白临界值时应灵活掌握,同时也应参考转铁蛋白饱和度百分比。假设使用的是贝克曼法或等效检测方法,采用罗氏法的中心需要调整现行实践指南推荐的口服铁剂和静脉铁剂给药临界值,以避免不给可能从补充铁剂中获益的不安腿综合征患者进行治疗。
西尔伯·M·H、布洛克·D·R、圣路易斯·E·K。血清铁蛋白测量结果因所用检测方法而异:对不安腿综合征铁治疗的影响。2025;21(1):65 - 67。