Freigeh George E, Fagen Hannah, Firn Janice
Division of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan Medical School, 24 Frank Lloyd Wright Drive, Suite 2100, Ann Arbor, MI, 48105, USA.
Department of Family Medicine and Community Health, University of Minnesota Medical School, 516 Delaware St. SE, Minneapolis, MN, 55455, USA.
HEC Forum. 2025 Jun;37(2):235-247. doi: 10.1007/s10730-024-09536-3. Epub 2024 Aug 22.
Limited data exist in the specific content of pediatric outpatient ethics consults as compared to inpatient ethics consults. Given the fundamental differences in outpatient and inpatient clinical care, we aimed to describe the distinctive nature of ethics consultation in the ambulatory setting. This is a retrospective review at a large, quaternary academic center of all outpatient ethics consults in a 6-year period. Encounter-level demographic data was recorded, and primary ethical issue and contextual features were identified using qualitative conceptual content analysis. A total of 48 consults were identified representing 44 unique patients. The most common primary ethical issue was beneficence and best interest concern comprising 20 (42%) consults, followed by refusal of recommended treatment comprising 11 (23%) consults and patient preference/assent comprising 5 (10%) consults. The most common contextual features were staff-family communication dispute/conflict comprising 28 (58%) consults, followed by legal involvement comprising 25 (52%) consults and quality of life comprising 19 (40%) consults. The most common consulting specialty was hematology/oncology. Ethical issues encountered in the provision of outpatient pediatric care are distinct and differ from those in inpatient consults. Further research is necessary to identify strategies and educational gaps in outpatient ethics consultation to increase its effectiveness and utilization.
与住院患者伦理咨询相比,儿科门诊伦理咨询的具体内容方面的数据有限。鉴于门诊和住院临床护理存在根本差异,我们旨在描述门诊环境中伦理咨询的独特性质。这是对一家大型四级学术中心6年期间所有门诊伦理咨询进行的回顾性研究。记录了每次会诊的人口统计学数据,并使用定性概念内容分析法确定了主要伦理问题和背景特征。共确定了48次咨询,涉及44名不同的患者。最常见的主要伦理问题是行善和最佳利益考量,占20次(42%)咨询,其次是拒绝推荐治疗,占11次(23%)咨询,患者偏好/同意占5次(10%)咨询。最常见的背景特征是工作人员与家属沟通方面的争议/冲突,占28次(58%)咨询,其次是法律介入,占25次(52%)咨询,生活质量占19次(40%)咨询。最常见的咨询专科是血液学/肿瘤学。门诊儿科护理中遇到的伦理问题与住院患者咨询中的问题不同且有区别。有必要进行进一步研究,以确定门诊伦理咨询中的策略和教育差距,以提高其有效性和利用率。