School of Digital Humanities and Computational Social Sciences, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology.
Institute on Aging, University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Health Psychol. 2024 Nov;43(11):791-802. doi: 10.1037/hea0001401. Epub 2024 Aug 22.
Does loneliness predict premature death? Much prior research suggests so, but this evidence draws primarily on populations from individualistic societies, such as North America and Western Europe. Here, we aimed to extend this evidence by testing a hypothesis that loneliness would predict greater mortality risk in collectivistic societies, where social interdependence is normatively sanctioned.
Using a harmonized dataset from two individualistic (England and the United States) and two collectivistic (Korea and Mexico) countries (combined = 41,869), we tested whether cultural contexts moderate the extent to which loneliness predicts 10-year all-cause mortality.
After adjustment of demographic variables and health behaviors, loneliness was associated with increased 10-year mortality in all four countries, with hazard ratios (HRs) of 1.13 in England, 1.21 in the United States and Mexico, and 1.51 in Korea. When health conditions were additionally controlled, this association became negligible in two individualistic countries, with HRs of 0.98 for both England and the United States. In contrast, the HR remained highly significant in Korea (HR = 1.27). Curiously, the mortality risk of loneliness in Mexico (HR = 1.03), another collectivistic country, was no different from the risks in England and the United States.
When people feel that they are chronically isolated from social networks, this perception can be fatal in Korea, but it is less so in the other three countries. Discussion focuses on other cultural factors, besides the cultural dimension of individualism-collectivism, that may account for the current finding. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
孤独是否会导致早逝?大量先前的研究表明确实如此,但这些证据主要来自个人主义社会的人群,例如北美和西欧。在这里,我们旨在通过测试一个假设来扩展这一证据,即孤独感在集体主义社会中会预测更高的死亡率,而社会相互依存在集体主义社会中是规范认可的。
我们使用来自两个个人主义(英国和美国)和两个集体主义(韩国和墨西哥)国家的协调数据集(共 41869 人),检验文化背景是否会调节孤独感对 10 年全因死亡率的预测程度。
在调整人口统计学变量和健康行为后,孤独感与所有四个国家的 10 年死亡率增加相关,英国的危险比(HR)为 1.13,美国和墨西哥为 1.21,韩国为 1.51。当进一步控制健康状况时,这种关联在两个个人主义国家变得微不足道,英国和美国的 HR 均为 0.98。相比之下,在韩国,这种关联仍然非常显著(HR = 1.27)。奇怪的是,墨西哥(HR = 1.03)作为另一个集体主义国家,孤独感的死亡风险与英国和美国没有区别。
当人们感到自己长期与社交网络隔绝时,这种感觉在韩国可能是致命的,但在其他三个国家则不然。讨论重点关注除个人主义-集体主义文化维度之外的其他文化因素,这些因素可能解释了目前的发现。