Pandya Haren, Patel Hiren, Vithalani Smit, Bhavsar Bijal, Shah Urvi, Chunawala Aliasgar
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Faculty of Dental Science, Nadiad, Gujarat, India.
Ann Maxillofac Surg. 2024 Jan-Jun;14(1):71-75. doi: 10.4103/ams.ams_205_23. Epub 2024 May 8.
Mandibular fractures are common injuries during maxillofacial trauma, and currently, open reduction and internal fixation are considered gold-standard treatments. There is a wide discussion about which plates give the best outcomes. Hence, we are conducting a biomechanical comparison of two plates for mandibular symphysis and angle fracture with finite element analysis (FEA). The aim of this study was to do a comparative study of FEA between the conventional and our new modified three-dimensional (3D) strut miniplate in mandibular fractures at symphysis and angle regions.
Finite element models of symphyseal and angle fractures of the mandible were developed. Each fracture model was then realigned and fixed by the conventional method 2.0 mm system, and our modified 3D strut plating method 2.0 mm system followed by the analysis of various stresses developed in plates and mandibular fracture area after application of load was observed in the study.
The modified 3D strut plating system with 2.0 mm miniplates is significantly better in preventing displacement of fracture segments by better distribution of forces compared to the conventional plating system. Rest of the parameters were within the permitted limits.
Modified 3D strut plating method was reasonably effective and superior in managing force-displacement compared to the conventional method of fixation for comminuted and unfavourable mandibular symphyseal fracture and angle fracture.
下颌骨骨折是颌面创伤中常见的损伤,目前,切开复位内固定被认为是金标准治疗方法。关于哪种钢板能取得最佳效果存在广泛讨论。因此,我们正在通过有限元分析(FEA)对两种用于下颌骨联合部和角部骨折的钢板进行生物力学比较。本研究的目的是对传统钢板与我们新改良的三维(3D)支撑微型钢板在下颌骨联合部和角部骨折的有限元分析进行对比研究。
建立下颌骨联合部和角部骨折的有限元模型。然后,每个骨折模型先用传统的2.0毫米系统方法进行重新复位和固定,再用我们改良的3D支撑钢板固定方法2.0毫米系统,之后观察在施加负荷后钢板和下颌骨骨折区域产生的各种应力。
与传统钢板固定系统相比,采用2.0毫米微型钢板的改良3D支撑钢板固定系统通过更好地分散力,在防止骨折段移位方面明显更优。其他参数均在允许范围内。
与传统的粉碎性和不利型下颌骨联合部骨折及角部骨折固定方法相比,改良3D支撑钢板固定方法在处理力与位移方面相当有效且更具优势。