Parrell Benjamin, Naber Chris, Kim Olivia A, Nizolek Caroline A, McDougle Samuel D
Waisman Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Wisconsin-Madison.
bioRxiv. 2024 Aug 16:2024.08.13.607718. doi: 10.1101/2024.08.13.607718.
Observed outcomes of our movements sometimes differ from our expectations. These sensory prediction errors recalibrate the brain's internal models for motor control, reflected in alterations to subsequent movements that counteract these errors (motor adaptation). While leading theories suggest that all forms of motor adaptation are driven by learning from sensory prediction errors, dominant models of speech adaptation argue that adaptation results from integrating time-advanced copies of corrective feedback commands into feedforward motor programs. Here, we tested these competing theories of speech adaptation by inducing planned, but not executed, speech. Human speakers (male and female) were prompted to speak a word and, on a subset of trials, were rapidly cued to withhold the prompted speech. On standard trials, speakers were exposed to real-time playback of their own speech with an auditory perturbation of the first formant to induce single-trial speech adaptation. Speakers experienced a similar sensory error on movement cancelation trials, hearing a perturbation applied to a recording of their speech from a previous trial at the time they would have spoken. Speakers adapted to auditory prediction errors in both contexts, altering the spectral content of spoken vowels to counteract formant perturbations even when no actual movement coincided with the perturbed feedback. These results build upon recent findings in reaching, and suggest that prediction errors, rather than corrective motor commands, drive adaptation in speech.
我们动作的实际结果有时与预期不同。这些感觉预测误差会重新校准大脑用于运动控制的内部模型,这体现在后续动作的改变上,这些改变会抵消这些误差(运动适应)。虽然主流理论认为所有形式的运动适应都是由从感觉预测误差中学习驱动的,但言语适应的主导模型认为,适应是通过将校正反馈命令的时间提前副本整合到前馈运动程序中实现的。在这里,我们通过诱导计划好但未执行的言语来测试这些相互竞争的言语适应理论。人类说话者(男性和女性)被提示说出一个单词,并且在一部分试验中,会迅速收到提示以抑制所提示的言语。在标准试验中,说话者会听到自己带有第一共振峰听觉扰动的实时语音回放,以诱导单次试验的言语适应。在运动取消试验中,说话者经历了类似的感觉误差,即在他们本应说话的时候,听到对他们前一次试验的语音记录施加的扰动。在这两种情况下,说话者都适应了听觉预测误差,即使没有实际动作与扰动反馈同时发生,也会改变所说话语元音的频谱内容以抵消共振峰扰动。这些结果建立在最近关于伸手动作的研究基础上,并表明预测误差而非校正运动命令驱动言语适应。