Najarzadegan Fereshteh, Eslamipour Faezeh
Department of Orthodontics, School of Dentistry, New York University, School of Dentistry, New York, USA.
Dental Research Center, Department of Oral Public Health and Orthodontics, Dental Research Institute, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran.
Dent Res J (Isfahan). 2024 Jul 4;21:30. eCollection 2024.
Smile esthetics can be subjective. This study aims to assess the effect of culture/geographic location on judging smile esthetics by comparing the perception of smile characteristics between American laypersons (Western culture) and Iranians (Eastern).
One hundred residents from each country were recruited for this analytical cross-sectional study. A frontal picture of a posed smile with standard norms which are mentioned in the Contemporary Orthodontics textbook by William R. Proffit was selected. Adobe Photoshop 7 was used to alter midline diastema, gingival display (GD), maxillary midline-to-face discrepancy, buccal corridor (BC), and smile arc. Images were given to groups to determine the most attractive and acceptable smile. Data were analyzed by Chi-square, Mann-Whitney, and Spearman correlation coefficient in SPSS-22 (α =0.05).
Americans were less critical in judging diastema ( < 0.001), GD ( = 0.013), and BC ( = 0.004) for smile attractiveness than Iranians. No difference was between the two groups in choosing the acceptability threshold and determining the most attractive smile except for BC ( = 0.002).
Overall, Americans were more tolerant of variations in smile characteristics than Iranians. Both groups agreed on most smiles. Therefore, it seems that it is reasonable to use similar standards for smile characteristics while considering the small differences.
微笑美学具有主观性。本研究旨在通过比较美国普通民众(西方文化)和伊朗人(东方文化)对微笑特征的认知,评估文化/地理位置对判断微笑美学的影响。
招募每个国家的100名居民参与这项分析性横断面研究。选用了威廉·R·普罗菲特所著《当代正畸学》教科书中提到的具有标准规范的正面 posed 微笑照片。使用Adobe Photoshop 7改变中线间隙、牙龈暴露度(GD)、上颌中线与面部的差异、颊廊(BC)和微笑弧度。将图像分发给各小组以确定最具吸引力和可接受的微笑。在SPSS - 22中采用卡方检验、曼 - 惠特尼检验和斯皮尔曼相关系数进行数据分析(α = 0.05)。
在判断微笑吸引力方面,美国人对间隙(<0.001)、牙龈暴露度(=0.013)和颊廊(=0.004)的评判比伊朗人更宽松。除颊廊外(=0.002),两组在选择可接受阈值和确定最具吸引力的微笑方面没有差异。
总体而言,美国人对微笑特征变化的容忍度高于伊朗人。两组对大多数微笑的看法一致。因此,考虑到细微差异,使用相似的微笑特征标准似乎是合理的。