Vanin Stefano, Tuccia Fabiola, Pradelli Jennifer, Carta Giuseppina, Giordani Giorgia
Department of Earth, Environmental and Life Sciences (DISTAV), University of Genoa, 16132 Genoa, Italy.
National Research Council, Institute for the Study of Anthropic Impact and Sustainability in the Marine Environment (CNR-IAS), 16149 Genova, Italy.
Insects. 2024 Aug 8;15(8):599. doi: 10.3390/insects15080599.
Diptera identification is fundamental in forensic entomology as well as in funerary archeoentomology, where the challenge is exacerbated by the presence of immature stages such as larvae and puparia. In these two developmental stages, specimens possess a very limited number of diagnostic features, and for puparia, there is also a lack of identification tools such as descriptions and identification keys. Morphological analysis, DNA-based techniques, and cuticular chemical analyses all show good potential for species identification; however, they also have some limitations. DNA-based identification is primarily hindered by the incompleteness of genetic databases and the presence of PCR inhibitors often co-extracted from the puparial cuticle. Chemical analysis of the cuticle is showing promising results, but this approach is also limited by the insufficient profile database and requires specific, expensive equipment, as well as trained personnel. Additionally, to ensure the repeatability of the analysis-a critical aspect in forensic investigations-and to preserve precious and unique specimens from museum collections, non-invasive protocols and techniques must be prioritized for species identification.
双翅目昆虫的鉴定在法医昆虫学以及丧葬考古昆虫学中至关重要,而幼虫和蛹等未成熟阶段的存在使这一挑战更加严峻。在这两个发育阶段,标本具有非常有限的诊断特征,而且对于蛹来说,还缺乏描述和鉴定检索表等鉴定工具。形态学分析、基于DNA的技术和表皮化学分析在物种鉴定方面都显示出良好的潜力;然而,它们也存在一些局限性。基于DNA的鉴定主要受到遗传数据库不完整以及经常从蛹表皮共提取的PCR抑制剂的阻碍。表皮的化学分析显示出有前景的结果,但这种方法也受到图谱数据库不足的限制,并且需要特定的、昂贵的设备以及训练有素的人员。此外,为确保分析的可重复性(这在法医调查中是一个关键方面)以及保护博物馆收藏的珍贵和独特标本,必须优先采用非侵入性方案和技术进行物种鉴定。