Sridhar Shela, Digidiki Vasileia, Ratner Leah, Kunichoff Dennis, Gartland Matthew G
Division of Global Health Equity, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, 75 Francis Street, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
François-Xavier Bagnoud Center for Health and Human Rights, Harvard University, 677 Huntington Ave, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
Children (Basel). 2024 Aug 5;11(8):944. doi: 10.3390/children11080944.
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Migrant children in family detention facilities often experience frequent relocations and prolonged stays in precarious living conditions. This frequent relocation results in fragmentation of necessary medical care, leading to delays and inadequate medical care. We aim to highlight the critical need for comprehensive medical documentation in immigration detention facilities, a fragmented health care system and potential harm to these children without appropriate medical documentation.
We conducted a retrospective review of 165 medical records from children detained at the Karnes County Family Residential Center between June 2018 and October 2020 to evaluate the adequacy of pediatric medical documentation in an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) family detention facility. Specific areas of interest included acute care, nutrition, immunization, developmental screening, and tuberculosis screening. Simple descriptive statistics were used to analyze the data.
Only 25% of 418 acute medical care visits included specific diagnoses. There was no documentation regarding follow-up recommendations upon release. 97% of children had a chest X-ray completed for tuberculosis screening, however no follow-up recommendations were documented for those with granulomas. Vaccination histories were inconsistently documented. No nutritional categorizations were completed despite 16% of children being at risk for malnutrition or already malnourished.
Our findings revealed significant gaps in documentation, particularly in medical decision-making and clinical reasoning. In a fragmented medical system, inadequate documentation can result in avoidable errors in diagnosis and management. Improving documentation practices is crucial to ensure that all children, regardless of immigration status, receive quality healthcare aligned with national and international standards.
背景/目的:被拘留在家庭拘留设施中的移民儿童经常经历频繁搬迁,并长期处于不稳定的生活条件下。这种频繁搬迁导致必要医疗护理的碎片化,造成医疗护理的延误和不足。我们旨在强调移民拘留设施中全面医疗记录的迫切需求,这是一个碎片化的医疗保健系统,且缺乏适当医疗记录会对这些儿童造成潜在伤害。
我们对2018年6月至2020年10月期间被拘留在卡恩斯县家庭居住中心的儿童的165份病历进行了回顾性审查,以评估移民和海关执法局(ICE)家庭拘留设施中儿科医疗记录的充分性。感兴趣的具体领域包括急性护理、营养、免疫接种、发育筛查和结核病筛查。使用简单的描述性统计分析数据。
418次急性医疗护理就诊中只有25%包含具体诊断。没有关于出院后随访建议的记录。97%的儿童进行了胸部X光结核病筛查,但对于有肉芽肿的儿童没有记录随访建议。疫苗接种史记录不一致。尽管16%的儿童有营养不良风险或已营养不良,但没有完成营养分类。
我们的研究结果揭示了记录方面的重大差距,特别是在医疗决策和临床推理方面。在碎片化的医疗系统中,记录不充分可能导致诊断和管理中出现可避免的错误。改进记录做法对于确保所有儿童,无论移民身份如何,都能获得符合国家和国际标准的优质医疗保健至关重要。