Physicians for Human Rights, New York, NY, USA.
Department of Family Medicine, Georgetown University School of Medicine, Washington, DC, USA.
BMC Public Health. 2022 Mar 23;22(1):575. doi: 10.1186/s12889-022-12967-7.
In the past decade, the U.S. immigration detention system regularly detained more than 30,000 people per day; in 2019 prior to the pandemic, the daily detention population exceeded 52,000 people. Inhumane detention conditions have been documented by internal government watchdogs, and news media and human rights groups who have observed over-crowding, poor hygiene and sanitation and poor and delayed medical care, as well as verbal, physical and sexual abuse.
This study surveyed health professionals across the United States who had provided care for immigrants who were recently released from immigration detention to assess clinician perceptions about the adverse health impact of immigration detention on migrant populations based on real-life clinical encounters. There were 150 survey responses, of which 85 clinicians observed medical conditions attributed to detention.
These 85 clinicians reported seeing a combined estimate of 1300 patients with a medical issue related to their time in detention, including patients with delayed access to medical care or medicine in detention, patients with new or acute health conditions such as infection and injury attributed to detention, and patients with worsened chronic or special needs conditions. Clinicians also provided details regarding sentinel cases, categorized into the following themes: Pregnant women, Children, Mentally Ill, COVID-19, and Other serious health issue.
This is the first survey, to our knowledge, of health care professionals treating individuals upon release from detention. Due to the lack of transparency by federal entities and limited access to detainees, this survey serves as a source of credible information about conditions experienced within immigration detention facilities and is a means of corroborating immigrant testimonials and media reports. These findings can help inform policy discussions regarding systematic changes to the delivery of healthcare in detention, quality assurance and transparent reporting.
在过去的十年中,美国移民拘留系统每天拘留的人数超过 3 万人;在 2019 年大流行之前,每天被拘留的人数超过 52000 人。内部政府监督机构、新闻媒体和人权组织都记录了不人道的拘留条件,他们观察到过度拥挤、卫生和环境卫生条件差以及医疗服务差和延误,以及言语、身体和性虐待。
本研究调查了美国各地为最近从移民拘留中获释的移民提供护理的医疗保健专业人员,以评估临床医生根据实际临床接触,对移民拘留对移民人口健康的不利影响的看法。共有 150 份调查回复,其中 85 名临床医生观察到与拘留有关的医疗状况。
这 85 名临床医生报告说,总共看到了 1300 名与拘留期间有关的医疗问题患者,其中包括在拘留期间延迟获得医疗或药物的患者、因拘留而出现新的或急性健康状况(如感染和受伤)的患者,以及因拘留而恶化的慢性或特殊需要状况的患者。临床医生还提供了有关哨点病例的详细信息,分为以下主题:孕妇、儿童、精神病患者、COVID-19 和其他严重健康问题。
据我们所知,这是首次对从拘留中获释的医疗保健专业人员进行的调查。由于联邦实体缺乏透明度以及对被拘留者的有限访问,该调查是了解移民拘留设施内所经历条件的可靠信息来源,也是证实移民证词和媒体报道的一种手段。这些发现可以帮助为有关在拘留中提供医疗保健、质量保证和透明报告的系统变革的政策讨论提供信息。