Rocha Felipe, Sibim Alessandra Cristiane, Molina-Flores Baldomero, Chiba de Castro Wagner Antonio, Kmetiuk Louise Bach, Alves Renato Vieira, Dos Santos André Luis de Sousa, Moreno Margarita Corrales, Faccini-Martínez Álvaro A, Cediel Natalia Margarita, Biondo Alexander Welker, Cosivi Ottorino, Vigilato Marco Antonio Natal
Pan American Center for Foot-and-Mouth Disease and Veterinary Public Health (PANAFTOSA/VPH), Pan American Health Organization (PAHO/WHO), Rio de Janeiro 25045-002, RJ, Brazil.
Latin-American Institute of Technology, Infrastructure and Territory, Federal University for Latin American Integration (UNILA), Foz do Iguaçu 85870-650, PR, Brazil.
Pathogens. 2024 Aug 21;13(8):710. doi: 10.3390/pathogens13080710.
One Health (OH) is an integrative approach to human, animal, and environmental health and can be used as a comprehensive indicator for comparative purposes. Although an OH index has been proposed for comparing cities, states, and countries, to date, no practical study has compared countries using this approach. Accordingly, this study aimed to assess OH initiatives using a survey with a veterinary public health focus. The questionnaire contained 104 quantitative questions and was sent to representatives of governmental institutions of 32 countries in the Americas. After exclusion criteria were considered, a total of 35 questionnaires from 17 countries were analyzed, with country names remaining undisclosed during the statistical analyses to protect potentially sensitive information. Principal component analysis (PCA) of health parameters in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) as a function of country perception (self-vector) showed that food safety was ranked higher than public policies ( = 0.009), and that both ( = 0.003) were ranked higher than institutional routines related to zoonosis programs. National policies in accordance with international standards, regulations, recommendations, and guidelines was considered the standout topic for public policy, with higher-ranking topics including standard. Meanwhile, challenging topics included tools, preparedness, governance, and research. Food safety showed both strengths and challenges in the coordination of its activities with other sectors. Food safety communication was scored as a strength, while foodborne diseases prevention was ranked as a challenge. Institutional routines for zoonosis maintained both strong and challenging topics in the execution and implementation of attributions and daily routine. Thus, the survey showed that topics such as access to and compliance with international guidelines and intercountry integration were ranked higher than in-country articulation, particularly among food safety, zoonoses, and environmental institutions.
同一健康(OH)是一种针对人类、动物和环境健康的综合方法,可用作比较目的的综合指标。尽管已有人提出用同一健康指数来比较城市、州和国家,但迄今为止,尚无实际研究采用这种方法对各国进行比较。因此,本研究旨在通过一项以兽医公共卫生为重点的调查来评估同一健康倡议。问卷包含104个定量问题,并发送给了美洲32个国家政府机构的代表。在考虑了排除标准后,共分析了来自17个国家的35份问卷,在统计分析过程中未披露国家名称以保护潜在的敏感信息。将拉丁美洲和加勒比地区(LAC)的健康参数作为国家认知(自身向量)的函数进行主成分分析(PCA),结果表明食品安全的排名高于公共政策(P = 0.009),且两者(P = 0.003)的排名均高于与人畜共患病项目相关的机构常规工作。符合国际标准、法规、建议和指南的国家政策被视为公共政策的突出主题,排名较高的主题包括标准。同时,具有挑战性的主题包括工具、准备情况、治理和研究。食品安全在与其他部门协调活动方面既有优势也有挑战。食品安全沟通被评为优势,而食源性疾病预防则被列为挑战。人畜共患病的机构常规工作在职责执行和日常工作中既有强项也有挑战主题。因此,调查显示,诸如获取和遵守国际准则以及国家间整合等主题的排名高于国内的明确表述,特别是在食品安全、人畜共患病和环境机构中。