Bruce R A, Hossack K F, Kusumi F, Day B, Kannagi T
Am Heart J. 1985 May;109(5 Pt 1):1020-6. doi: 10.1016/0002-8703(85)90244-3.
Acute effects of placebo, sustained-release nitroglycerin, diltiazem capsules, and the combination of both drugs were monitored in nine stable angina patients. They were randomized to receive either placebo or 13 mg of slow-release nitroglycerin orally (double-blind). This was followed in 1 hour by 120 mg of diltiazem orally, given to all patients (unblinded). Invasive hemodynamic measurements were made before and after each treatment at supine and sitting rest, two levels of submaximal, and at maximal exercise and twice in recovery. Compared to the control test at maximal exercise, sustained-release nitroglycerin increased aerobic capacity 24%, lowered peripheral resistance -32%, and lowered systemic pressure -23%, while the respective changes with placebo were -3%, 5%, and 2%. When diltiazem was added to placebo compared to the control test, there was a 4% increase in oxygen consumption and -9% and -4% reduction in systemic resistance and systemic pressure, respectively. The addition of diltiazem to nitroglycerin was associated with a 20% increase in oxygen consumption a -42% reduction in systemic resistance and a -32% reduction in systemic pressure. Two patients who received nitroglycerin plus diltiazem experienced symptomatic hypotension, while one patient who received placebo plus diltiazem experienced hypotension. These side effects caused the study to be terminated prematurely. Thus, although the combination of nitroglycerin and diltiazem had a greater effect on afterload than either drug alone, the combination did not provide greater improvement in cardiac performance.
在9名稳定型心绞痛患者中监测了安慰剂、缓释硝酸甘油、地尔硫䓬胶囊以及两种药物联合使用的急性效应。他们被随机分组,口服接受安慰剂或13毫克缓释硝酸甘油(双盲)。1小时后,给所有患者口服120毫克地尔硫䓬(非盲)。在每次治疗前和治疗后,于仰卧位和坐位休息时、两个次极量水平、极量运动时以及恢复过程中进行两次有创血流动力学测量。与极量运动时的对照试验相比,缓释硝酸甘油使有氧能力提高24%,外周阻力降低32%,体循环压力降低23%,而安慰剂的相应变化分别为降低3%、升高5%和升高2%。与对照试验相比,在安慰剂基础上加用地尔硫䓬时,耗氧量增加4%,体循环阻力和体循环压力分别降低9%和4%。在硝酸甘油基础上加用地尔硫䓬使耗氧量增加20%,体循环阻力降低42%,体循环压力降低32%。两名接受硝酸甘油加地尔硫䓬治疗的患者出现症状性低血压,而一名接受安慰剂加地尔硫䓬治疗的患者出现低血压。这些副作用导致研究提前终止。因此,尽管硝酸甘油和地尔硫䓬联合使用对后负荷的影响比单独使用任何一种药物都大,但联合使用并未在心脏功能改善方面提供更大的益处。