Rev Sci Tech. 2024 Aug;43:79-86. doi: 10.20506/rst.43.3520.
Quantifying the impact of poor animal health outcomes on human health represents a complex challenge. Using the disability-adjusted life year (DALY) metric as an endpoint, this article discusses how animal health outcomes can impact humans through three key processes: directly through zoonotic disease, indirectly via changes in yields and their impacts on nutrition and wealth, and finally, through indirect features associated with the agricultural industry, such as pharmaceuticals and climate change. For each process, the current state of the art and feasibility of global DALY-associated estimates are discussed. Existing frameworks for zoonoses already consider some key pathogens; ensuring completeness in the pathogens considered and consistency in methodological decisions is an important next step. For diet, risk factor frameworks enable a calculation of attributable DALYs; however, significant economic methodological developments are needed to ensure that local production changes are appropriately mapped to both local and global changes in dietary habits. Concerning wealth-related impacts, much work needs to be done on method development. Industry-related impacts require a focus on key research topics, such as attribution studies for animal antimicrobial resistance contributing to human outcomes. For climate change, a critical next step is identifying to what extent associated industry emissions are amenable to change should animal health outcomes improve. Allocation of finite funds to improve animal health must also consider the downstream impact on humans. Leveraging DALYs enables comparisons with other human health-related decisions and would represent a transformative way of approaching animal health decision-making should the obstacles in this article be addressed and new methods be developed.
量化动物健康状况不佳对人类健康的影响是一个复杂的挑战。本文使用残疾调整生命年(DALY)作为终点,讨论了动物健康状况如何通过三个关键过程影响人类:直接通过人畜共患病,间接通过产量变化及其对营养和财富的影响,以及最后通过与农业相关的间接特征,如药物和气候变化。对于每个过程,讨论了全球与 DALY 相关估计的现状和可行性。现有人畜共患病框架已经考虑了一些关键病原体;确保考虑的病原体完整,并在方法决策上保持一致,是下一步的重要工作。对于饮食,风险因素框架可以计算归因于 DALY;然而,需要在经济方法学方面进行重大发展,以确保当地生产变化与当地和全球饮食习惯的变化进行适当的映射。关于与财富相关的影响,需要在方法开发方面做很多工作。行业相关的影响需要关注关键的研究课题,如对动物抗生素耐药性导致人类疾病的归因研究。对于气候变化,下一步的关键是确定在多大程度上可以通过改善动物健康来改变相关行业的排放。在有限的资金中分配用于改善动物健康的资金,也必须考虑到对人类的下游影响。利用 DALY 可以与其他与人类健康相关的决策进行比较,如果本文中提到的障碍得到解决并开发出新的方法,那么这将代表一种具有变革性的方法来处理动物健康决策。