Ogbeiwi Osahon, Ilyas Aysia, Harper Mark, Khan Wajid
Research & Development Department, South West Yorkshire Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, Fieldhead Hospital, Wakefield, WF1 3SP, UK.
J Racial Ethn Health Disparities. 2024 Sep 5. doi: 10.1007/s40615-024-02168-w.
Ethnic inequalities in high-income countries result in higher risk of mental illness and lower access to healthcare services for migrant populations than the majority White populations. This literature review examined evidence of the responsible barriers. A systematic search of six databases (Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection; eBook Collection [EBSCOhost]; CINAHL; GreenFILE; Library, Information Science & Technology Abstracts; and MEDLINE) was done using search terms. Eighteen recent, locally accessible studies conducted in six major resettlement countries were selected following PRISMA guidelines and the extracted evidence was analysed descriptively and thematically. Three main themes of ethnic mental health differentials of Black and Asian migrants were identified: access to services (13 studies), risk of mental illness (7 studies), and experience of care services (7 studies). Their access disparities revealed migrants suffer inequalities in service utilisation (5 studies) and greater obstacles to receiving care (8 studies). Their higher risk of mental illness was related to over-diagnosis of psychosis (2 studies), higher prevalence (4 studies), and exposure to predisposing factors (3 studies). Migrants experienced poorer quality and outcomes of care (3 studies), and use of restraint (2 studies) and seclusion (1 study) and expressed fear and mistrust of services (2 studies). The common ethnic barriers in service delivery were language and cultural difficulties, systemic discrimination and marginalisation, and social stigmatisation. It is proposed that systemic racism as well as communication and cultural difficulties are the core determinants of migrants' ethnic disparities of accessing mental health services in these major host countries.
在高收入国家,与多数白人人口相比,移民群体面临着更高的精神疾病风险,且获得医疗服务的机会更少。这篇文献综述研究了造成这些问题的相关障碍的证据。使用搜索词对六个数据库(心理学与行为科学合集;电子书合集[EBSCOhost];护理学与健康领域数据库;绿色档案;图书馆、信息科学与技术文摘;以及医学期刊数据库)进行了系统检索。按照系统评价和荟萃分析优先报告的条目(PRISMA)指南,选取了在六个主要移民安置国家开展的18项近期本地可获取的研究,并对提取的证据进行了描述性和主题性分析。确定了黑人和亚洲移民在种族心理健康差异方面的三个主要主题:获得服务(13项研究)、精神疾病风险(7项研究)以及护理服务体验(7项研究)。他们在获得服务方面的差距表明,移民在服务利用方面存在不平等(5项研究),在接受护理方面面临更大障碍(8项研究)。他们较高的精神疾病风险与精神病的过度诊断(2项研究)、较高的患病率(4项研究)以及易患因素的暴露(3项研究)有关。移民经历了较差的护理质量和结果(3项研究),遭遇了约束措施的使用(2项研究)和隔离(1项研究),并表达了对服务的恐惧和不信任(2项研究)。服务提供中常见的种族障碍包括语言和文化困难、系统性歧视和边缘化以及社会污名化。有人提出,系统性种族主义以及沟通和文化困难是这些主要东道国移民在获得心理健康服务方面存在种族差异的核心决定因素。