Aging and lifestyle-related diseases, such as cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, cancer, and neurodegenerative disorders, are major global health challenges. These conditions are often linked to redox imbalances, where cells fail to regulate reactive redox species (RRS), leading to oxidative stress and cellular damage. Although antioxidants are known to neutralize harmful RRS, their clinical efficacy remains inconsistent. One reason for this inconsistency is the inadequacy of current in vitro models to accurately mimic in vivo redox conditions. This study addresses the gap in understanding the heterogeneity of redox responses in cells by using metabolically primed human dermal fibroblasts (NHDF), a model relevant for precision mitochondrial medicine. We investigated how metabolic priming, which enhances mitochondrial bioenergetics, influences redox responses to oxidative stress induced by hydrogen peroxide (HO) and tert-butyl hydroperoxide (tBHP). Specifically, we explored the impact of cell population density and cell cycle distribution on redox dynamics. Our findings indicate that NHDF cells cultured in oxidative phosphorylation-promoting medium (OXm) exhibit significantly larger variability in oxidative stress responses. This variability suggests that enhanced mitochondrial bioenergetics necessitates a constant regulation of the cellular redox machinery, potentially leading to heterogeneous responses. Additionally, cells grown in OXm showed increased mitochondrial polarization and a lower percentage of cells in the G2/M phase, contributing to the observed heterogeneity. Key factors influencing this variability included cell population density at the time of oxidant exposure and fluctuations in cell cycle distribution. Our results highlight the necessity of employing multiple oxidants in metabolic priming models to achieve a comprehensive understanding of oxidative stress responses and redox regulation mechanisms. Furthermore, the study emphasizes the need to refine in vitro models to better reflect in vivo conditions, which is crucial for the development of effective redox-based therapeutic strategies.