Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Houston, TX.
School of Communication Science and Disorders, Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2024 Oct 8;67(10):3595-3611. doi: 10.1044/2024_JSLHR-24-00153. Epub 2024 Sep 11.
This study investigated relationships within and between perceptual, acoustic, and kinematic measures in speakers with and without dysarthria due to Parkinson's disease (PD) across different clarity conditions. Additionally, the study assessed the predictive capabilities of selected acoustic and kinematic measures for intelligibility and articulatory precision ratings.
Forty participants, comprising 22 with PD and 18 controls, read three phrases aloud using conversational, less clear, and more clear speaking conditions. Acoustic measures and their theoretical kinematic parallel measures (i.e., acoustic and kinematic distance and vowel space area [VSA]; second formant frequency [F2] slope and kinematic speed) were obtained from the diphthong /aɪ/ and selected vowels in the sentences. A total of 368 listeners from crowdsourcing provided ratings for intelligibility and articulatory precision. The research questions were examined using correlations and linear mixed-effects models.
Intelligibility and articulatory precision ratings were highly correlated across all speakers. Acoustic and kinematic distance, as well as F2 slope and kinematic speed, showed moderately positive correlations. In contrast, acoustic and kinematic VSA exhibited no correlation. Among all measures, acoustic VSA and kinematic distance were robust predictors of both intelligibility and articulatory precision ratings, but they were stronger predictors of articulatory precision.
The findings highlight the importance of measurement selection when examining cross-domain relationships. Additionally, they support the use of behavioral modifications aimed at eliciting larger articulatory gestures to improve intelligibility in individuals with dysarthria due to PD.
本研究调查了患有帕金森病(PD)导致的构音障碍和无构音障碍的说话者在不同清晰度条件下的感知、声学和运动学测量值之间和之内的关系。此外,该研究还评估了选定的声学和运动学测量值对可理解性和发音准确性评分的预测能力。
40 名参与者,包括 22 名 PD 患者和 18 名对照组,使用会话、较不清晰和更清晰的说话条件朗读三个短语。从句子中的双元音 /aɪ/ 和选定元音中获取声学测量值及其理论运动学平行测量值(即声学和运动学距离和元音空间面积[VSA];第二共振峰频率[F2]斜率和运动学速度)。来自众包的 368 位听众对可理解性和发音准确性进行了评分。使用相关性和线性混合效应模型来研究研究问题。
所有说话者的可理解性和发音准确性评分高度相关。声学和运动学距离以及 F2 斜率和运动学速度呈中度正相关。相比之下,声学和运动学 VSA 没有相关性。在所有测量值中,声学 VSA 和运动学距离是可理解性和发音准确性评分的强有力预测指标,但它们对发音准确性的预测能力更强。
研究结果强调了在检查跨域关系时选择测量值的重要性。此外,它们支持使用旨在引发更大发音运动的行为改变,以提高 PD 导致的构音障碍患者的可理解性。