School of Public Health, Fudan University, Shanghai, China.
School of Public Health, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China.
Front Public Health. 2024 Aug 29;12:1355239. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2024.1355239. eCollection 2024.
China's National Essential Medicines Policy (NEMP) has been implemented for over 15 years; yet empirical evidence on its long-term impacts is lacking, particularly in remote and rural regions. This study aims to assess the short-and long-term effects of NEMP on the drug availability, price, and usage in a deprived rural county in southwestern China.
A quasi-experimental design was employed, featuring a single-group pre-and-post comparison. We gathered 74,436 procurement records spanning from 2009 to 2016 from the drug warehouses of local medical institutions. Pharmaceutical data were analyzed quarterly, considering various policy and therapeutic attributes. Fisher's Drug Price Index (DPI-F) was calibrated for the retail and wholesale prices of a consistent collection of 405 medications. We conducted interrupted time-series analysis to examine the immediate and enduring impacts of NEMP's initial (commencing in January 2011) and second (starting from December 2015) stages.
After initiation of NEMP, the number of available essential medicines surged by 115 but subsequently faced a steady quarterly decline (-9.1) in township healthcare centers (THCs, primary care). Conversely, county hospitals (secondary care) initially saw a reduction of 40 in drug availability but later exhibited a steady increase (+4.2 per quarter) up to the second-stage NEMP. Regarding price, THCs encountered abrupt (-26.1%/-15.9% in retail/wholesale price) and sustained (-0.2%/-0.3% per quarter) price drops after NEMP. The immediate price change after NEMP in county hospitals were milder but significant in non-essential medicines, and long-term declines were also observed in all drugs. As for total sales, a significant long-term disparity emerged between THCs (+0.9% per quarter) and county hospitals (+3.3% per quarter). Following the second-stage NEMP, retail prices in county hospitals further decreased, although wholesale prices did not; however, following price upward trends were observed in both THCs and county hospitals. Lastly, the influences of NEMP varied across different therapeutical categories of medicines.
NEMP has successfully regulated drug prices in primary and secondary healthcare facilities in remote and rural areas, both short-term and long-term. However, a remarkable disparity in medicine availability and utilization was observed between different levels of facilities over time. Continuous monitoring is essential, with increased attention needed on the uneven impacts of the policy on diverse drugs, facilities, regions, and demographics.
中国的国家基本药物政策(NEMP)已经实施了超过 15 年;然而,缺乏其长期影响的经验证据,尤其是在偏远和农村地区。本研究旨在评估 NEMP 对中国西南部一个贫困农村县的药物可获得性、价格和使用的短期和长期影响。
采用准实验设计,采用单组前后比较。我们从当地医疗机构的药品仓库中收集了 2009 年至 2016 年的 74436 份采购记录。每季度分析药物数据,考虑各种政策和治疗属性。校准了 Fisher 药品价格指数(DPI-F),以反映 405 种药物的零售和批发价格。我们进行了中断时间序列分析,以检验 NEMP 初始阶段(2011 年 1 月开始)和第二阶段(2015 年 12 月开始)的即时和持久影响。
NEMP 实施后,基本药物的可获得数量增加了 115 种,但随后在乡镇卫生院(初级保健)中每季度稳定下降(-9.1%)。相比之下,县医院(二级保健)最初的药物供应减少了 40 种,但随后稳定增加(每季度增加 4.2%),直到 NEMP 的第二阶段。关于价格,乡镇卫生院在 NEMP 后立即出现急剧下降(零售/批发价格分别下降 26.1%/15.9%),随后持续下降(每季度下降 0.2%/0.3%)。NEMP 后县医院的即时价格变化较为温和,但在非基本药物中较为显著,所有药物也呈现出长期下降趋势。至于总销售额,乡镇卫生院(每季度增长 0.9%)和县医院(每季度增长 3.3%)之间出现了显著的长期差异。NEMP 的第二阶段实施后,县医院的零售价格进一步下降,尽管批发价格没有下降;然而,随后观察到乡镇卫生院和县医院的价格都呈现上升趋势。最后,NEMP 的影响因药物治疗类别而异。
NEMP 成功地调节了偏远和农村地区初级和二级医疗机构的药品价格,无论是短期还是长期。然而,随着时间的推移,不同级别医疗机构的药物可获得性和利用率之间存在显著差异。需要持续监测,并需要更加关注该政策对不同药物、设施、地区和人口的不均衡影响。