Abbott Noelle, Nip Ignatius, Love Tracy
San Diego State University/University of California San Diego Joint Doctoral Program in Language and Communicative Disorders, San Diego, CA, United States.
School of Speech, Language, and Hearing Sciences, San Diego State University, San Diego, CA, United States.
Front Lang Sci. 2024;3. doi: 10.3389/flang.2024.1394742. Epub 2024 Aug 26.
This study examined whether children with Developmental Language Disorder (DLD) have knowledge of binding principles (i.e., linking pronouns to their structurally licensed antecedent) during real-time sentence processing (cross-modal priming, real-time) and overt comprehension (sentence-picture matching, interpretative) and whether rate of speech impacted access to that knowledge. Fourteen children with DLD participated in two experiments, with sentences presented auditorily at either a regular or slow speech rate. Sentences were matched except to contain a pronoun, reflexive, or noun phrase (control) in the same syntactic position. Experiment (1) used a cross-modal picture priming paradigm to test real-time pronoun-antecedent linking abilities at both rates of speech. Children were instructed to make a binary decision during the uninterrupted auditory presentation of a sentence to a visually presented image (of the antecedent) at the offset of a pronoun, a reflexive, or a control noun. Response times between conditions (e.g., pronoun vs. control noun) were compared to determine whether participants showed evidence of facilitative priming (faster response times in the pronoun than control noun condition) at either speech rate. Experiment (2) used an auditory sentence-picture-matching task to test final comprehension of similar sentences containing a pronoun or reflexive. Accuracy was compared across both speech rates. For Experiment (1), children with DLD did not show evidence of real-time pronoun-antecedent priming at the regular speech rate. However, when sentences were slowed, they showed facilitative priming for the pronoun condition. For experiment (2), children with DLD performed at-chance when interpreting sentences with pronouns regardless of speech rate. While children with DLD have been shown to have difficulty processing sentences containing anaphors (such as pronouns), results suggest that this is not due to loss of intrinsic knowledge of binding principles. By slowing the rate of speech input, we showed that children with DLD do have access to that knowledge and can make the correct link during real-time processing between a pronoun and its structurally licensed antecedent (Experiment 1) but need more time to do so. However, the effect of slowed speech input does not extend to final comprehension (Experiment 2).
本研究考察了患有发展性语言障碍(DLD)的儿童在实时句子处理(跨模态启动,实时)和显性理解(句子-图片匹配,解释性)过程中是否具备约束原则的知识(即将代词与其结构上许可的先行词联系起来),以及语速是否会影响对该知识的获取。14名患有DLD的儿童参与了两项实验,句子以正常语速或慢速通过听觉呈现。句子除了在相同句法位置包含代词、反身代词或名词短语(对照)外均进行了匹配。实验(1)使用跨模态图片启动范式来测试两种语速下的实时代词-先行词连接能力。在代词、反身代词或对照名词出现后,向儿童视觉呈现一个先行词的图像,并在句子不间断的听觉呈现过程中要求他们做出二元决策。比较不同条件(如代词与对照名词)之间的反应时间,以确定参与者在两种语速下是否表现出促进性启动的证据(代词条件下的反应时间比对照名词条件下更快)。实验(2)使用听觉句子-图片匹配任务来测试包含代词或反身代词的类似句子的最终理解。比较两种语速下的准确率。对于实验(1),患有DLD的儿童在正常语速下没有表现出实时代词-先行词启动的证据。然而,当句子语速放慢时,他们在代词条件下表现出促进性启动。对于实验(2),患有DLD的儿童在解释含代词的句子时,无论语速如何,表现均为随机水平。虽然已表明患有DLD的儿童在处理包含指代成分(如代词)的句子时有困难,但结果表明这并非由于约束原则的内在知识缺失。通过放慢语音输入速度,我们发现患有DLD的儿童确实能够获取该知识,并且在实时处理过程中能够在代词与其结构上许可的先行词之间建立正确的联系(实验1),但需要更多时间来做到这一点。然而,放慢语音输入的效果并未扩展到最终理解(实验2)。