Dubey Ravish, Telles Arina, Nikkel James, Cao Chang, Gewirtzman Jonathan, Raymond Peter A, Lee Xuhui
School of the Environment, Yale University, New Haven, CT 06511, USA.
Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven, CT 06511, USA.
Sensors (Basel). 2024 Aug 31;24(17):5675. doi: 10.3390/s24175675.
The study comprehensively evaluates low-cost CO sensors from different price tiers, assessing their performance against a reference-grade instrument and exploring the possibility of calibration using different machine learning techniques. Three sensors (Sunrise AB by Senseair, K30 CO by Senseair, and GMP 343 by Vaisala) were tested alongside a reference instrument (Los Gatos precision greenhouse gas analyzer). The results revealed differences in sensor performance, with the higher cost Vaisala sensors exhibiting superior accuracy. Despite its lower price, the Sunrise sensors still demonstrated reasonable accuracy. Meanwhile, the K30 sensor measurements displayed higher variability and noise. Machine learning models, including linear regression, gradient boosting regression, and random forest regression, were employed for sensor calibration. In general, linear regression models performed best for extrapolating data, whereas decision tree-based models were generally more useful in handling non-linear datasets. Notably, a stack ensemble model combining these techniques outperformed the individual models and significantly improved sensor accuracy by approximately 65%. Overall, this study contributes to filling the gap in intercomparing CO sensors across different price categories and underscores the potential of machine learning for enhancing sensor accuracy, particularly in low-cost sensor applications.
该研究全面评估了不同价格层级的低成本一氧化碳(CO)传感器,将其性能与参考级仪器进行对比,并探索使用不同机器学习技术进行校准的可能性。三种传感器(Senseair公司的Sunrise AB、Senseair公司的K30 CO以及Vaisala公司的GMP 343)与一台参考仪器(洛斯加托斯精密温室气体分析仪)一起进行了测试。结果显示了传感器性能的差异,价格较高的Vaisala传感器表现出更高的精度。尽管Sunrise传感器价格较低,但仍显示出合理的精度。同时,K30传感器的测量结果显示出更高的变异性和噪声。包括线性回归、梯度提升回归和随机森林回归在内的机器学习模型被用于传感器校准。总体而言,线性回归模型在数据外推方面表现最佳,而基于决策树的模型通常在处理非线性数据集时更有用。值得注意的是,将这些技术结合起来的堆叠集成模型优于单个模型,并显著提高了传感器精度,提高幅度约为65%。总体而言,这项研究有助于填补不同价格类别CO传感器相互比较方面的空白,并强调了机器学习在提高传感器精度方面的潜力,特别是在低成本传感器应用中。