Esper Garrett W, Anil Utkarsh, Cavaleri Salvatore G, Furgiuele David L, Zaretsky Jonah, Konda Sanjit R, Egol Kenneth A
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital, NYU Langone Health, New York, NY, USA.
Division of Cardiology, NYU Langone Health, New York, NY, USA.
HSS J. 2024 May;20(2):237-244. doi: 10.1177/15563316231158546. Epub 2023 Mar 9.
There may be disagreement among stakeholders on the need for preoperative cardiac screening for elderly hip fracture patients. : We sought to assess preoperative workup perceptions among physicians for hip fracture patients across specialties, specifically considering a patient's cardiovascular risk. : A case-based survey was distributed to 50 physicians in each of the 4 departments involved in preoperative patient care: orthopedic surgery (OS), anesthesiology (A), cardiology (C), and hospital medicine (HM). The survey asked about which clinical presentations required a cardiology consult, as well as about further preoperative imaging and laboratory work. Single score intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to compare agreement. : Of the 200 surveys sent out, 33 responses (16.5% response rate) were received. Between all specialties, there was 72% agreement about preoperative cardiology consult need (intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC] = 0.063 or poor) and 71% agreement about preoperative transthoracic echocardiogram (TTE) need (ICC = 0.188 or poor). Within each specialty (A, C, HM, OS) ICCs measuring agreement for the need for cardiology consult were 0.812 (good), 0.561 (moderate), 0.457 (poor), and 0.414 (poor), respectively, and for the need for preoperative TTE were 0.852 (good), 0.441 (poor), 0.848 (good), and 0.188 (poor), respectively. Common preoperative testing requested included complete blood count, basic metabolic panel in all cases, and electrocardiogram with troponins if perioperative acute coronary syndrome symptoms were present. : This survey suggests that there may be varying levels of agreement within specialties and poor agreement between specialties on the need for cardiology consultation and preoperative imaging for hip fracture patients. This suggests the need for established, reliable preoperative workup protocols with input from different specialties to streamline preoperative care for patients before hip fracture surgery.
利益相关者对于老年髋部骨折患者术前心脏筛查的必要性可能存在分歧。我们试图评估各专业医生对髋部骨折患者术前检查的看法,特别考虑患者的心血管风险。一项基于病例的调查被分发给参与术前患者护理的4个科室的50名医生:骨科手术(OS)、麻醉学(A)、心脏病学(C)和医院医学(HM)。该调查询问了哪些临床表现需要心脏科会诊,以及进一步的术前影像学和实验室检查。使用单评分组内相关系数(ICC)来比较一致性。在发出的200份调查问卷中,收到了33份回复(回复率为16.5%)。在所有专业之间,对于术前心脏科会诊需求的一致性为72%(组内相关系数[ICC]=0.063或较差),对于术前经胸超声心动图(TTE)需求的一致性为71%(ICC=0.188或较差)。在每个专业(A、C、HM、OS)中,衡量心脏科会诊需求一致性的ICC分别为0.812(良好)、0.561(中等)、0.457(较差)和0.414(较差),对于术前TTE需求的ICC分别为0.852(良好)、0.441(较差)、0.848(良好)和0.188(较差)。常见的术前检查要求包括全血细胞计数,所有病例均进行基本代谢指标检测,以及如果出现围手术期急性冠状动脉综合征症状则进行心电图加肌钙蛋白检测。这项调查表明,各专业内部对于髋部骨折患者心脏科会诊需求和术前影像学检查的一致性水平可能不同,而各专业之间的一致性较差。这表明需要制定既定的、可靠的术前检查方案,并纳入不同专业的意见,以简化髋部骨折手术前患者的术前护理。