Loy Michelle H, Fatato Tim
Department of Medicine, Weill Cornell Medicine, Cornell University, New York, NY, USA.
Department of Pediatrics, Weill Cornell Medicine, Cornell University, New York, NY, USA.
Glob Adv Integr Med Health. 2024 Sep 11;13:27536130241283789. doi: 10.1177/27536130241283789. eCollection 2024 Jan-Dec.
Research on Qi Gong (QG) supports promising health benefits. Both interest and use of QG in U.S. adults has increased over the past decade. Shared Medical Appointments (SMAs) are a novel, cost-effective, and time efficient health care delivery approach associated with patient and clinician satisfaction.
A telehealth delivered QG SMA was pilot tested among a diverse demographic population within an integrative medicine practice at an academic medical center to assess feasibility and acceptability.
This was a feasibility/acceptability pilot study conducted at a large New York City academic medical center's Integrative Health and Wellness center from January to July 2023. A QG instructor-acupuncturist and an integrative medicine physician-acupuncturist co-led 3 separate series (5 Element QG, Eight-Section Brocade, and Joint-Mobilizing/Sinew Strengthening exercises) of weekly 30-45-minute sessions of QG SMA on a weekday afternoon via telemedicine. The first session included an overview of QG and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) research while follow-up sessions included a check-in, didactic demonstration followed by QG practice, and a debrief to answer questions. Video links were provided for home practice. Surveys assessing satisfaction were sent pre/post series.
18 sessions of QG SMA were offered over a 6-month period. A total of 40 unique participants from diverse demographics (gender, race/ethnicity, primary residence) attended, for a total of 197 virtual visits. A total of 20 participants enrolled in Series 1 (8 weeks), 23 enrolled in Series 2 (7 weeks), and 16 enrolled in Series 3 (3cweeks). For each session, group attendance ranged from 8-16 with an average of 11 participants. Attendance was high with participants attending an average of 72% of the sessions. Participants attended 88% of the first 8-week series, 54% of the second 7-week series, and 60% of the third series. Participant interest persisted over time with 35% of the 40 participants attending more than 1 series, and 12.5% attending all 3 series. Participants' diagnoses and health symptoms included pain (62.5%), cancer (45%) anxiety/depression (40%), cardiovascular disease (CVD) or metabolic conditions (32.5%), gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms/diagnoses (27.5%), stress (22.5%), osteopenia/osteoporosis (17.5%), and insomnia (17.5%). Pre-series [n = 27] participants endorsed symptoms including sleep disturbances, fatigue, pain, stress, weakness, GI symptoms, psychological symptoms, hot flashes, and brain fog. Post-program survey results [n = 11] suggested QG program addressed common symptoms including fatigue, insomnia, anxiety, stress, pain, weakness, and gastrointestinal symptoms. Participants reported incorporating QG, breathing techniques, and meditation into their daily routine. All participants reported their goals were met and that they would recommend the program to others. Regarding delivery preferences, 73% preferred telehealth, 27% hybrid, and none preferred in-person. Participants appreciated the format, new skills, community, and instructors.
While the Virtual QG SMA series provided to diverse demographic population with mixed diagnoses is feasible, acceptable, and shows promising positive impact in this pilot, caution in interpreting the data is advised due to the low response rate of the post-program survey. Robust studies with longer follow-ups are recommended.
对气功(QG)的研究表明其具有显著的健康益处。在过去十年中,美国成年人对气功的兴趣和应用均有所增加。共享医疗预约(SMA)是一种新颖、经济高效且节省时间的医疗服务提供方式,与患者和临床医生的满意度相关。
在一家学术医疗中心的综合医学实践中,对不同人口统计学特征的人群进行了一项远程医疗气功共享医疗预约的试点测试,以评估其可行性和可接受性。
这是一项于2023年1月至7月在纽约市一家大型学术医疗中心的综合健康与养生中心进行的可行性/可接受性试点研究。一名气功教练兼针灸师和一名综合医学医生兼针灸师通过远程医疗,在工作日下午共同主持了3个独立系列(五元素气功、八段锦和关节活动/筋肉强化练习)的每周30 - 45分钟的气功共享医疗预约课程。第一节课包括气功和中医(TCM)研究概述,后续课程包括签到、理论演示,然后是气功练习,以及问答环节。提供视频链接供家庭练习。在系列课程前后发放评估满意度的调查问卷。
在6个月内共提供了18节气功共享医疗预约课程。共有40名来自不同人口统计学特征(性别、种族/民族、主要居住地)的独特参与者参加,总共进行了197次虚拟就诊。共有20名参与者参加了系列1(8周),23名参加了系列2(7周),16名参加了系列3(3周)。每次课程的小组出勤人数在8 - 16人之间,平均为11名参与者。出勤率很高,参与者平均参加了72%的课程。参与者参加了第一个8周系列课程的88%,第二个7周系列课程的54%,以及第三个系列课程的60%。随着时间推移,参与者的兴趣持续存在,40名参与者中有35%参加了不止一个系列,12.5%参加了所有3个系列。参与者的诊断和健康症状包括疼痛(62.5%)、癌症(45%)、焦虑/抑郁(40%)、心血管疾病(CVD)或代谢疾病(32.5%)、胃肠道(GI)症状/诊断(27.5%)、压力(22.5%)、骨质减少/骨质疏松(17.5%)和失眠(17.5%)。系列课程前[n = 27]的参与者认可的症状包括睡眠障碍、疲劳、疼痛、压力、虚弱、胃肠道症状、心理症状、潮热和脑雾。课程后调查结果[n = 11]表明,气功课程解决了常见症状,包括疲劳、失眠、焦虑、压力、疼痛、虚弱和胃肠道症状。参与者报告将气功、呼吸技巧和冥想融入了日常生活。所有参与者都报告他们的目标达成了,并且会向其他人推荐该课程。关于授课方式偏好,73%的人更喜欢远程医疗,27%的人更喜欢混合模式,没有人更喜欢面对面授课。参与者对课程形式、新技能、社区和教师表示赞赏。
虽然向具有多种诊断的不同人口统计学特征人群提供的虚拟气功共享医疗预约系列是可行的、可接受的,并且在本次试点中显示出有希望的积极影响,但由于课程后调查的低回复率,建议在解释数据时谨慎。建议进行更有力的长期随访研究。