Medullary thyroid cancer (MTC) is a relatively rare thyroid malignancy, constituting a small percentage of all thyroid cancer cases. Even more rare is the occurrence of mixed MTC and papillary thyroid cancer (PTC), found in a very small fraction of MTC cases. These cancers originate from different cell types with distinct developmental origins. The coexistence of MTC and PTC in the same patient raises questions about whether this occurrence is merely coincidental or if there is an underlying genetic link. We present the case of a woman with metastatic mixed MTC and PTC. A 61-year-old woman with a history of Hashimoto's disease was found to have bilateral thyroid nodules; the largest (1.7 cm) was in the right lobe. This nodule met fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy criteria and was found to have a follicular neoplasm of undetermined significance. The patient elected to pursue total thyroidectomy instead of lobectomy given the presence of bilateral nodules. Postoperative pathology showed mixed medullary carcinoma (pT3b) and follicular variant papillary thyroid microcarcinoma (pT1a) involving the right lobe with positive anterior and posterior margins and lymphovascular invasion. Preoperative calcitonin was not checked. However, post-thyroidectomy calcitonin was 1599 pg/mL. She underwent central and right lateral neck dissection which showed 27 out of 35 lymph nodes were positive for malignancy. Postoperative calcitonin dropped to 38.7 pg/mL. She then established care in our endocrine clinic. Screening for pheochromocytoma and primary hyperparathyroidism was normal. She underwent external beam radiation of the neck. A year after her initial surgery, her neck ultrasound and computed tomography (CT) studies show no signs of local or distant anatomic recurrence. Her thyroglobulin level remains undetectable, carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) within normal range, and calcitonin stable at about 20 pg/mL. She is on levothyroxine 100 mcg daily with thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) at a suppression goal of <0.1 mIU/L. Mixed PTC and MTC is poorly studied due to its rarity. The origin of these mixed tumors is unclear, but some suggest that they arise from neoplastic changes of remnant multipotent cells in the thyroid. While patients with PTC often have a favorable prognosis following surgical therapy, MTC has a more aggressive course. We suggest monitoring patients like ours for both MTC and PTC, as if present in isolation. Our case highlights the clinical aspects of this condition and our current knowledge of its pathophysiology.