Bauer Tyler M, Pienta Michael J, Wu Xiaoting, Thompson Michael P, Hawkins Robert B, Pruitt Andrew L, Delucia Alphonse, Lall Shelly C, Pagani Francis D, Likosky Donald S
Department of Cardiac Surgery, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Mich.
Department of Cardiac Surgery, St Joseph Mercy, Ann Arbor, Mich.
JTCVS Open. 2024 May 29;20:101-111. doi: 10.1016/j.xjon.2024.04.018. eCollection 2024 Aug.
Cardiac surgeons experience unpredictable overnight operative responsibilities, with variable rest before same-day, first-start scheduled cases. This study evaluated the frequency and associated impact of a surgeon's overnight operative workload on the outcomes of their same-day, first-start operations.
A statewide cardiac surgery quality database was queried for adult cardiac surgical operations between July 1, 2011, and March 1, 2021. Nonemergency, first-start, Society of Thoracic Surgeons predicted risk of mortality operations were stratified by whether or not the surgeon performed an overnight operation that ended after midnight. A generalized mixed effect model was used to evaluate the effect of overnight operations on a Society of Thoracic Surgeons composite outcome (5 major morbidities or operative mortality) of the first-start operation.
Of all first-start operations, 0.4% (239/56,272) had a preceding operation ending after midnight. The Society of Thoracic Surgeons predicted risk of morbidity and mortality was similar for first-start operations whether preceded by an overnight operation or not (overnight operation: 11.3%; no overnight operation: 11.7%, = .42). Unadjusted rates of the primary outcome were not significantly different after an overnight operation (overnight operation: 13.4%; no overnight operation: 12.3%, = .59). After adjustment, overnight operations did not significantly impact the risk of major morbidity or mortality for first-start operations (adjusted odds ratio, 1.1, = .70).
First-start cardiac operations performed after an overnight operation represent a small subset of all first-start Society of Thoracic Surgeons predicted risk operations. Overnight operations do not significantly influence the risk of major morbidity or mortality of first-start operations, which suggests that surgeons exercise proper judgment in determining appropriate workloads.
心脏外科医生需承担不可预测的夜间手术职责,在当日首例预定手术前的休息时间也各不相同。本研究评估了外科医生夜间手术工作量的频率及其对当日首例手术结果的相关影响。
查询了一个全州范围的心脏手术质量数据库,以获取2011年7月1日至2021年3月1日期间的成人心脏外科手术信息。非急诊、首例、胸外科医师协会预测有死亡风险的手术,根据外科医生是否进行了午夜后结束的夜间手术进行分层。使用广义混合效应模型来评估夜间手术对胸外科医师协会首例手术综合结局(5种主要并发症或手术死亡率)的影响。
在所有首例手术中,0.4%(239/56,272)的手术前有午夜后结束的手术。无论首例手术前是否有夜间手术,胸外科医师协会预测的发病和死亡风险相似(夜间手术:11.3%;无夜间手术:11.7%,P = 0.42)。夜间手术后主要结局的未调整发生率无显著差异(夜间手术:13.4%;无夜间手术:12.3%,P = 0.59)。调整后,夜间手术对首例手术的主要并发症或死亡风险无显著影响(调整后的优势比为1.1,P = 0.70)。
夜间手术后进行的首例心脏手术占胸外科医师协会预测有风险的所有首例手术的一小部分。夜间手术不会显著影响首例手术的主要并发症或死亡风险,这表明外科医生在确定适当工作量时行使了恰当的判断力。