Connor Jennifer J
Memorial University of Newfoundland, Canada.
J Hist Med Allied Sci. 2024 Sep 21. doi: 10.1093/jhmas/jrae031.
Many accounts, autobiographical and scholarly, emphasize how volunteers portrayed their work in the mission established for fishers by British physician Wilfred Grenfell in Newfoundland and Labrador: as escapist adventure. Scholars have not studied women physicians or their motivations to volunteer, however. This oversight derives from their small number combined with lack of knowledge about this mission's distinction from the foreign medical missions and domestic frontier missions that drew many women physicians to permanent positions. This study therefore discusses two American physicians, Alfreda B. Withington (1860-1951) and Emma E. Musson (1862-1913), who volunteered for summer service with this mission in 1907 and 1909, respectively. Through their publications, biographical sources, and clinical accounts, it reveals the appeal to them of such temporary, accessible volunteer service as a working vacation that rejuvenated. Importantly, it counters the skewed perspective of contemporary accounts in which the connection of Withington and Musson to an international celebrity, Wilfred Grenfell, overrode fuller considerations of their own lives, careers, and experiences. Finally, this examination suggests possible differences in their volunteerism between women physicians and their male counterparts: along with other women professionals, medical women often incorporated volunteer vacation experience into a continuum of similar endeavors in their careers.
许多自传及学术性记述都强调,志愿者们如何描述他们在英国医生威尔弗雷德·格伦费尔于纽芬兰和拉布拉多为渔民设立的传教任务中的工作:即逃避现实的冒险。然而,学者们尚未研究女医生或她们做志愿者的动机。这种忽视源于她们人数较少,以及对这项任务与吸引许多女医生担任固定职位的外国医疗传教任务和国内边疆传教任务之间差异的了解不足。因此,本研究讨论了两位美国医生,阿尔弗雷达·B·威辛顿(1860 - 1951)和艾玛·E·马森(1862 - 1913),她们分别于1907年和1909年志愿参加了这项任务的暑期服务。通过她们的出版物、传记资料和临床记述,揭示了这种临时的、可参与的志愿服务对她们的吸引力,这种服务就像是一次让人恢复活力的工作假期。重要的是,它反驳了当代记述中那种片面的观点,即威辛顿和马森与国际名人威尔弗雷德·格伦费尔的关联掩盖了对她们自己的生活、职业和经历的更全面考量。最后,这项研究表明女医生和男医生在志愿服务方面可能存在差异:与其他女性专业人员一样,女医生常常将志愿者假期经历融入到她们职业生涯中一系列类似的努力中。