Lightowlers Carly, Duke Karen
Department of Sociology, Social Policy and Criminology, School of Law and Social Justice, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
Department of Criminology and Sociology, School of Law, Middlesex University, London, UK.
Nordisk Alkohol Nark. 2024 Aug;41(4):448-463. doi: 10.1177/14550725241256465. Epub 2024 Jun 6.
In 2018, the UK Government published its Serious Violence Strategy setting out the Government's commitment to adopting a public health approach to 'serious violence' in England and Wales and encouraging a multi-agency, whole system public health approach to violence prevention. There has been very little research attention and commentary on the roles of alcohol and illegal drugs in the construction of "serious violence" within the Strategy. Drawing on thematic analysis of key policy documents, the ways in which drugs and alcohol have been conceptualised in recent violence policy in the English and Welsh context are explored through the analytical framework of "framing". The overwhelming emphasis on violence associated with the drugs market has skewed attention towards exceptional and sensationalist forms of "serious" violence and diverted it from more common and widespread forms of "everyday" violence, including domestic and alcohol-related violence. Omitting these from the policy purview has implications for those affected and how resources are allocated. To advance inclusive and holistic violence prevention, a wider framing of violence is required and both illegal drugs and alcohol need to be embedded for meaningful working across populations and organisational boundaries.
2018年,英国政府发布了《严重暴力行为战略》,阐述了政府致力于在英格兰和威尔士采用公共卫生方法应对“严重暴力行为”,并鼓励采取多机构、全系统的公共卫生方法预防暴力行为。在该战略中,关于酒精和非法药物在“严重暴力行为”构成中的作用,研究关注和评论极少。借助对关键政策文件的主题分析,通过“框架构建”分析框架,探讨了在英格兰和威尔士背景下,毒品和酒精在近期暴力政策中的概念化方式。对与毒品市场相关暴力行为的过度强调,使注意力偏向异常和耸人听闻的“严重”暴力形式,而偏离了更常见、更广泛的“日常”暴力形式,包括家庭暴力和与酒精相关的暴力。将这些排除在政策范围之外,对受影响者以及资源分配方式都有影响。为推动包容性和整体性的暴力预防,需要对暴力进行更广泛的框架构建,并且必须将非法药物和酒精纳入其中,以便在不同人群和组织边界进行有意义的工作。