Characteristics and Practices of High-Performing Centers in Organ Donor Identification and Referral: A Qualitative Study.

BACKGROUND

The identification and referral (ID&R) of potential organ donors to provincial organ donation organizations (ODOs) is a critical first step in the organ donation process. However, even in provinces with mandatory referral legislation, there remains variability in ID&R rates across critical care units, with some units demonstrating high performance despite experiencing similar constraints associated with existing structures, policies, and practices.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to identify the enablers and specific strategies that high-performing critical care units leveraged to achieve their exceptional performance.

DESIGN

We conducted a descriptive qualitative study to inform ID&R improvement efforts as part of a positive deviance initiative.

SETTING

We identified three high-performing critical care units as study sites.

PARTICIPANTS

Clinicians working in identified critical care units.

METHODS

At each site, we interviewed clinical team members about their perceptions and experiences of ID&R. Data analysis followed a thematic analysis approach.

RESULTS

We outline three themes describing how the high-performing hospitals achieve strong ID&R practices. First, all units demonstrated a high degree of integration between the concepts of high-quality end-of-life care and organ donation. Team members were consistently notified of successful transplants stemming from their unit, and all missed ID&Rs were tracked and discussed. Second, participants described a team approach with strong medical leadership, where all team members embrace their role in ensuring that no potential donor is missed. Finally, the units adopted strategies to support and simplify ID&R such as collectively simplifying triggers for referral, developing strong working relationships with provincial donor coordinators, and creating informal avenues of communication between clinicians and donor coordinators.

LIMITATIONS

The lack of comparable data for potential organ donor referral rates across Canada impacted our ability to identify high-performing hospitals based on data. Instead, we contacted the ODOs directly to identify high-performing units that met our criteria. Second, our study sample was limited to three hospital sites from three different provinces and the three hospitals perform organ recovery and transplant on-site.

CONCLUSION

Critical care units can adopt strategies and implement interventions to support ID&R improvement efforts. We provide examples informed by this study. We also highlight considerations that require attention when engaging in this work such as ensuring that all team members are aware of changes in care plans and physicians consistently engage in discussions about organ donation. Local medical leadership is critical to supporting these changes.