Department of Medicine, University of Wisconsin (UW)-Madison, Madison, WI, USA.
School of Information, UW-Madison, Madison, WI, USA.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Sep 27;24(1):1049. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-06017-6.
Empathy declines during medical training, despite its importance.
In this randomized controlled trial, we assessed the impact of Zoom improv on medical student empathy using a concurrent mixed-methods approach. Quantitative assessment with three survey tools and qualitative assessment by content analysis of Zoom session field notes were conducted.
Zoom improv participants had higher empathy scores in perspective-taking and fantasy and lower scores in personal distress compared with the control group. Medical students who participated in Zoom improv exercised emotional expression, active listening, and giving "gifts," which apply to healthcare settings in which affirming team members with empathic concern can advance communication, patient rapport, and teamwork.
This pilot study highlights promising findings for the incorporation of Zoom improv in medical education, including enhanced empathy, self-reflection, and understanding how these skills impact work in healthcare. Future studies may expand on the optimal timing to teach improv. Future studies conducted on virtual platforms may also further investigate our finding that the fantasy domain of empathy increases after Zoom improv sessions, whereas this increase in fantasy was absent from previous in-person studies. Given the increase in telehealth and virtual medical visits, exercising empathy skills through a screen during training may be an important addition to medical curricula.
尽管同理心很重要,但在医学培训过程中,同理心会下降。
在这项随机对照试验中,我们采用同期混合方法评估了 Zoom 即兴对医学生同理心的影响。使用三个调查工具进行定量评估,并通过对 Zoom 会议现场记录的内容分析进行定性评估。
与对照组相比,Zoom 即兴组的同理心在换位思考和幻想方面的得分更高,而在个人困扰方面的得分更低。参加过 Zoom 即兴的医学生们练习了情绪表达、积极倾听和给予“礼物”,这些技能适用于医疗保健环境,在这种环境中,以同理心的关怀来肯定团队成员可以促进沟通、患者关系和团队合作。
这项初步研究强调了将 Zoom 即兴纳入医学教育的有前景的发现,包括同理心、自我反思和理解这些技能如何影响医疗保健工作的增强。未来的研究可能会扩展教授即兴的最佳时机。在虚拟平台上进行的未来研究也可能进一步探讨我们的发现,即在 Zoom 即兴课程之后,同理心的幻想领域会增加,而这种幻想的增加在以前的实地研究中是不存在的。鉴于远程医疗和虚拟医疗访问的增加,在培训期间通过屏幕练习同理心技能可能是医学课程的一个重要补充。