Zweifel Lynn Anna Barbara, Storp Jens Julian, Vietmeier Friederike Elisabeth, Danzer Moritz Fabian, Merté Ralph-Laurent, Eter Nicole, Brücher Viktoria Constanze
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Muenster Medical Center, 48149 Muenster, Germany.
Institute of Biostatistics and Clinical Research, University of Muenster, 48149 Muenster, Germany.
Life (Basel). 2024 Sep 17;14(9):1171. doi: 10.3390/life14091171.
To compare success rates of trabeculectomy (TE) and Preserflo MicroShunt (PMS) in heterogenous glaucoma cohorts with regards to different pre- and postoperative therapeutic regimens. Data of 187 glaucoma patients who either received TE (73 eyes) or PMS implantation (114 eyes) between January 2018 and December 2022 were retrospectively evaluated. Surgical success and failure rates were analyzed within six months of follow-up. Intraocular pressure (IOP) development over the course of follow-up was compared between both groups. Tertiary outcome measures were best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), number and type of medications, frequency of postoperative complications and revision surgeries. Outcome measures underwent additional assessment based on subgroup categorizations, and failure time hazard ratios were computed. The success rates were comparable between both procedures (TE: 54.1%, PMS: 60.0%; = 0.17). Both procedures showed significant IOP reduction ( < 0.01); however, overall IOP reduction was greater in the TE group than in the PMS group (TE: Reduction by 12 mmHg (188.9%), PMS: Reduction by 7 mmHg (51.3%); = 0.01). The number of topical medications decreased significantly in both groups over the course of follow-up (TE: 4 to 0, PMS: 3 to 0; < 0.01). While the number of complications and revision surgeries were similar in both groups, the time interval until the first revision surgery within the TE group was significantly shorter (TE: 13.5 d, PMS: 163 d; = 0.01) than within the PMS group. No difference could be detected between TE and PMS with regard to the follow-up regimen. In particular, there was no significant difference in the need for 5-floururacil injections postoperatively ( = 0.29). Less invasive glaucoma surgery with the PMS appeared comparable to the TE within a heterogenous glaucoma cohort with regards to IOP development and freedom from medication.
比较小梁切除术(TE)和Preserflo微分流器(PMS)在异质性青光眼队列中针对不同术前和术后治疗方案的成功率。对2018年1月至2022年12月期间接受TE(73只眼)或PMS植入(114只眼)的187例青光眼患者的数据进行回顾性评估。在随访的六个月内分析手术成功率和失败率。比较两组随访期间的眼压(IOP)变化情况。三级结局指标为最佳矫正视力(BCVA)、药物数量和类型、术后并发症频率及翻修手术情况。根据亚组分类对结局指标进行额外评估,并计算失败时间风险比。两种手术的成功率相当(TE:54.1%,PMS:60.0%;P = 0.17)。两种手术均显示眼压显著降低(P < 0.01);然而,TE组的总体眼压降低幅度大于PMS组(TE:降低12 mmHg(188.9%),PMS:降低7 mmHg(51.3%);P = 0.01)。随访期间两组的局部用药数量均显著减少(TE:从4种减至0种,PMS:从3种减至0种;P < 0.01)。虽然两组的并发症和翻修手术数量相似,但TE组首次翻修手术的时间间隔明显短于PMS组(TE:13.5天,PMS:163天;P = 0.01)。TE和PMS在随访方案方面未发现差异。特别是,术后5-氟尿嘧啶注射的需求无显著差异(P = 0.29)。在异质性青光眼队列中,就眼压变化和无需用药而言,采用PMS的侵入性较小的青光眼手术似乎与TE相当。