Department of Health Promotion, School of Health Sciences, University of Galway, H91TK33 Galway, Ireland.
Department of Human Resource Management, Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities, Kinneret College on the Sea of Galilee, Zemach Emek HaYarden Mobile Post 15132, Israel.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2024 Sep 3;21(9):1173. doi: 10.3390/ijerph21091173.
Workplace bullying is broadly defined as a detrimental form of negative micro-political interaction(s) incorporating a range of aggressive interpersonal behaviours. While targeted toxic behaviour based upon legally protected grounds such as ethnicity, gender, or sexual orientation is conceptualised as harassment, this paper positions harassment as a constituent subset of workplace bullying-distinct, but inextricably linked to the broader landscape of workplace predation and incivility. Meta-analyses of cross-sectional and longitudinal studies demonstrate a robust relationship between being bullied and compromised health, and some sectors, e.g., education, display higher than average levels of exposure, suggesting that contexts matter. The higher education sector is the focus of this scoping review. High rates of bullying have been reported in Higher Education Institutions (HEIs), where many of the organisational factors that drive bullying are present. One systematic literature review has been carried out on bullying in HEIs, reviewing papers prior to 2013. Since the sector has seen considerable contextual change since that time, another review is timely. This systematic scoping review aims to identify the volume, range, nature, and characteristics of studies of workplace bullying in HEIs between 2003 and 2023, with a specific focus on how the of HEIs contributes to the enactment and/or the response to workplace bullying. To this end, 3179 records were identified, with 140 papers charted to identify methods, institution, population, and country. Forty-seven papers were subjected to full-text review for the exploration of contextual factors. Priorities for future research lie in addressing the pernicious effects of neoliberal governance models as well as the complex and intersecting power relations that are unique to higher education.
工作场所欺凌被广泛定义为一种有害的消极微观政治互动形式,包含一系列攻击性的人际行为。虽然以种族、性别或性取向等受法律保护的理由为目标的有毒行为被概念化为骚扰,但本文将骚扰视为工作场所欺凌的一个组成部分——虽然不同,但与工作场所掠夺和不文明的更广泛领域紧密相连。横断面和纵向研究的荟萃分析表明,被欺凌与健康受损之间存在强有力的关系,一些部门,如教育部门,暴露程度高于平均水平,这表明背景很重要。高等教育部门是本范围界定审查的重点。高等教育机构(HEIs)报告了很高的欺凌率,许多导致欺凌的组织因素都存在。已经对 HEIs 中的欺凌行为进行了一项系统的文献综述,审查了 2013 年之前的论文。自那时以来,该部门的背景发生了相当大的变化,因此另一次审查是及时的。这项系统的范围界定审查旨在确定 2003 年至 2023 年期间高等教育机构工作场所欺凌的研究数量、范围、性质和特征,特别关注高等教育机构的背景如何促进或应对工作场所欺凌。为此,确定了 3179 条记录,其中 140 篇论文用于确定方法、机构、人口和国家。对 47 篇论文进行全文审查,以探讨背景因素。未来研究的重点在于解决新自由主义治理模式的有害影响,以及高等教育特有的复杂和交叉权力关系。