MacDonald N E, Collison S, Wolfish N, McLaine P N, Mackenzie A M
CMAJ. 1985 Dec 15;133(12):1211-3.
To determine the effectiveness of precleansing with chlorhexidine gluconate-cetrimide in reducing the contamination rate of bagged urine specimens, 62 infants admitted to a children's hospital were randomly assigned to either receive (32 infants) or not receive (30) cleansing before bag application. Perimeatal swabs were taken before bag application and, in the treated group, after cleansing. Of the specimens from the treated group 69% were found to be contaminated, compared with 73% of those from the no-cleansing group. Chlorhexidine was ineffective in eliminating the perimeatal flora in 75% of the infants. The same organisms were present on the perimeatal swab and in the urine specimen in 95% of the infants in the treated group and 96% of those in the no-cleansing group. To estimate the contamination rate of urine specimens routinely cultured in the laboratory, 200 consecutive specimens (142 midstream and 58 bagged) were cultured. The contamination rate of the midstream urine specimens was 15%, compared with 66% for the bagged specimens. The cost of laboratory processing of contaminated bagged urine specimens at the hospital in 1983 may have been as high as $13 365. Chlorhexidine cleansing does not appear to be cost-effective. Further randomized controlled studies are needed to evaluate the effectiveness of other cleansing agents in reducing the contamination rate of bagged urine specimens.
为了确定使用葡萄糖酸氯己定 - 溴化十六烷基三甲铵进行预清洁对降低袋装尿液标本污染率的有效性,一家儿童医院收治的62名婴儿被随机分为两组,一组(32名婴儿)在应用尿袋前接受清洁,另一组(30名婴儿)不接受清洁。在应用尿袋前以及治疗组清洁后采集尿道口拭子。治疗组标本中69%被发现受到污染,未清洁组的这一比例为73%。75%的婴儿使用氯己定无法消除尿道口菌群。治疗组95%的婴儿和未清洁组96%的婴儿尿道口拭子和尿液标本中存在相同的微生物。为了估计实验室常规培养的尿液标本的污染率,对200份连续标本(142份中段尿和58份袋装尿)进行培养。中段尿标本的污染率为15%,袋装标本的污染率为66%。1983年该医院处理受污染袋装尿液标本的实验室成本可能高达13365美元。氯己定清洁似乎不具有成本效益。需要进一步的随机对照研究来评估其他清洁制剂在降低袋装尿液标本污染率方面的有效性。