Department of Emergency Medicine, Chitwan Medical College, Bharatpur, Nepal.
Emergency Department, Doncaster and Bassetlaw Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Doncaster, UK and QiMET Medical Institute, QiMET International Ltd, Sheffield, UK.
Leadersh Health Serv (Bradf Engl). 2024 Sep 30;37(4):477-498. doi: 10.1108/LHS-12-2023-0100.
Emergency medicine can save lives and in 2018 the World Health Assembly passed resolution 72.16 ensuring the role of emergency care in all health systems. With a continued global shortage of emergency physicians, with many low-medium-income countries (LMIC) still to develop emergency medicine as a speciality, the role of emergency nurses is critical to deliver the WHO Emergency Care System Framework (WHO, 2018). Emergency medicine doctors play a critical role in collaborating with nurses, in emergency medicine where nurses are often the first clinicians are often the first clinicians to interact with patients in emergency care settings, making up the majority of health-care professionals in LMIC (Mamalelala, 2024). Yet emergency nursing has yet to become established in Nepal, where nurses are often recruited to emergency departments, without having received any training in emergency or critical care treatment and management. The purpose of this paper is to outline a collaborative leadership approach to co-design an airway, breathing, circulation, disability, exposure (ABCDE) structured approach to an emergency nursing training module designed for nurses to feel empowered in the emergency department and to report on its findings.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: This study draws upon mixed methodology research, enrolling 30 nurses ( = 30) from an emergency department in a tertiary hospital in Nepal through three stages of the project: Stage 1: training module co-design, collaborative leadership exploring the rationale for a training module and core features of design based on the ABCDE of emergency medicine; Stage 2: quantitative data were collected to assess baseline pre- and post-intervention knowledge and follow-up knowledge assessment at 30 and 45 days; Stage 3: qualitative data were collected with 24/30 (80%) nurses to evaluate the impact and application of the nurses ABCDE learning 7 months post-training. The qualitative survey was undertaken using online Google Forms.
Nurses were fully engaged in the co-design and collaboration of the development of an ABCDE training module which was delivered over 3 h. Full engagement was secured from all nurses in the department, and there were statistically significant advances in ABCDE emergency knowledge from the baseline, however, this knowledge began to decrease at 30 and 45 days. A follow-up qualitative survey was distributed to nurses seven months after training with an 80% return rate, which reported a range of examples of how nurses were continuing to apply their learning in practice.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: This training module for emergency nurses was designed collaboratively from the "bottom up" in a tertiary hospital in Nepal, recognising the need to develop emergency nursing in the emergency department. The data revealed promising findings, while knowledge decreased from the post-training questionnaire, qualitative evidence revealed significant changes in practice, with the greatest reported change in the management of the airway. While this training module has made a difference in the quality of care provided, there is a need for a country-wide strategy in this area otherwise it is likely that such an initiative will only be developed by hospitals at a local level (Lecky, 2014). Education and training initiatives for nurses that focus on an evidence-based approach to clinical practice can bridge the workforce gap in the short term, however, the Government of Nepal must decide on establishing a recognised post-graduate sub-specialty in emergency nursing, the duration of training, who should be trained and what curriculum should be followed (Lecky, 2014).
急诊医学可以拯救生命,2018 年世界卫生大会通过了第 72.16 号决议,确保了急救护理在所有卫生系统中的作用。由于全球急诊医生短缺,许多中低收入国家(LMIC)仍在将急诊医学发展为一个专业,因此急诊护士的作用对于实施世卫组织紧急护理系统框架(世卫组织,2018 年)至关重要。在急诊医学中,医生与护士密切合作,护士往往是与患者首先互动的临床医生,在 LMIC 中,护士往往构成了大多数医疗保健专业人员(Mamalelala,2024 年)。然而,尼泊尔的急诊护理尚未建立,在那里,护士通常被招募到急诊部门,而没有接受过急诊或重症监护治疗和管理方面的任何培训。本文旨在概述一种协作领导方法,共同设计一个气道、呼吸、循环、残疾、暴露(ABCDE)结构化方法,为护士设计一个急诊护理培训模块,使他们在急诊部门感到有能力,并报告其调查结果。
方法/方法/方法:本研究采用混合方法研究,通过项目的三个阶段,从尼泊尔一家三级医院的急诊部门招募了 30 名护士(n=30):阶段 1:培训模块共同设计,协作领导探索培训模块的基本原理和设计的核心特征,基于急诊医学的 ABCDE;阶段 2:收集定量数据,以评估干预前和干预后的基线知识,并在 30 和 45 天进行随访知识评估;阶段 3:通过在线 Google 表格对 24/30(80%)名护士进行定性数据收集,以评估护士在培训后 7 个月内 ABCDE 学习的影响和应用。
护士充分参与了 ABCDE 培训模块的共同设计和协作,该模块在 3 小时内完成。部门内所有护士都充分参与,在 ABCDE 急救知识方面取得了统计学上显著的进步,然而,这一知识在 30 天和 45 天开始下降。在培训后七个月向护士发放了一份后续定性调查,回复率为 80%,报告了一些护士如何继续在实践中应用所学知识的例子。
原创性/价值:这个为急诊护士设计的培训模块是在尼泊尔的一家三级医院从“底层”合作设计的,认识到需要在急诊部门发展急诊护理。数据显示了有希望的发现,尽管从培训后的问卷中知识有所下降,但定性证据显示实践中发生了重大变化,气道管理方面的变化最大。虽然这个培训模块在提供的护理质量方面产生了影响,但在这方面需要有一个全国性的战略,否则这种举措可能只会由当地的医院在局部层面上开展(Lecky,2014 年)。专注于循证临床实践方法的护士教育和培训计划可以在短期内弥合劳动力差距,但是,尼泊尔政府必须决定在急诊护理方面建立一个公认的研究生专业,包括培训的持续时间、谁应该接受培训以及应该遵循什么课程(Lecky,2014 年)。