Lareyre Fabien, D'Oria Mario, Caradu Caroline, Jongkind Vincent, Di Lorenzo Gilles, Smeds Matthew R, Nasr Bahaa, Raffort Juliette
Department of Vascular Surgery, Hospital of Antibes Juan-les-Pins, Antibes, France.
Université Côte d'Azur, CNRS, UMR7370, LP2M, Nice, France.
EJVES Vasc Forum. 2024 Jul 16;62:57-63. doi: 10.1016/j.ejvsvf.2024.07.037. eCollection 2024.
Large language models and artificial intelligence (AI) based chatbots have brought new insights in healthcare, but they also raise major concerns. Their applications in vascular surgery have scarcely been investigated to date. This international survey aimed to evaluate the perceptions and feedback from vascular surgeons on the use of AI chatbots in vascular surgery.
This international open e-survey comprised 50 items that covered participant characteristics, their perceptions on the use of AI chatbots in vascular surgery, and their user experience. The study was designed in accordance with the Checklist for reporting Results of Internet E-Surveys and was critically reviewed and approved by international members of the European Vascular Research Collaborative (EVRC) prior to distribution. Participation was open to self reported health professionals specialised (or specialising) in vascular surgery, including residents or fellows.
Of the 342 individuals who visited the survey page, 318 (93%) agreed to participate; 262 (82.4%) finished the survey and were included in the analysis. Most were consultants or attending physicians (64.1%), most declared not having any training or education related to AI in healthcare (221; 84.4%), and 198 (75.6%) rated their knowledge about the abilities of AI chatbots between average to very poor. Interestingly, 95 participants (36.3%) found that AI chatbots were very useful or somewhat useful in clinical practice at this stage and 229 (87.4%) agreed that they should be systematically validated prior to being used. Eighty participants (30.5%) had specifically tested it for questions related to clinical practice and 59 (73.8%) of them experienced issues or limitations.
This international survey provides an overview of perceptions of AI chatbots by vascular surgeons and highlights the need to improve knowledge and training of health professionals to better evaluate, define, and implement their use in vascular surgery.
基于大语言模型和人工智能(AI)的聊天机器人给医疗保健领域带来了新的见解,但也引发了重大担忧。迄今为止,它们在血管外科手术中的应用几乎未得到研究。这项国际调查旨在评估血管外科医生对在血管外科手术中使用AI聊天机器人的看法和反馈。
这项国际开放式电子调查包含50个项目,涵盖参与者特征、他们对在血管外科手术中使用AI聊天机器人的看法以及他们的用户体验。该研究是根据互联网电子调查结果报告清单设计的,并在分发前由欧洲血管研究协作组织(EVRC)的国际成员进行了严格审查和批准。参与对象为自称专门从事(或正在专门从事)血管外科手术的卫生专业人员,包括住院医师或研究员。
在访问调查页面的342人中,318人(93%)同意参与;262人(82.4%)完成了调查并纳入分析。大多数是顾问医生或主治医生(64.1%),大多数人表示没有接受过任何与医疗保健领域AI相关的培训或教育(221人;84.4%),198人(75.6%)将他们对AI聊天机器人能力的了解评为中等至非常差。有趣的是,95名参与者(36.3%)发现在现阶段AI聊天机器人在临床实践中非常有用或有些用处,229人(87.4%)同意在使用前应对其进行系统验证。80名参与者(30.5%)专门针对与临床实践相关的问题对其进行了测试,其中59人(73.8%)遇到了问题或限制。
这项国际调查概述了血管外科医生对AI聊天机器人的看法,并强调需要提高卫生专业人员的知识和培训,以便更好地评估、定义和在血管外科手术中实施其应用。