Kalbermatten Natalie, Curca Razvan, Grigorescu Alexandru, Mosoiu Daniela, Pop Florina, Poroch Vladimir, Rosiu Ariana, Achimas-Cadariu Patriciu, Strasser Florian
Clinic Medical Oncology and Hematology, Cantonal Hospital, St.Gallen, Switzerland.
Spitalul Judetean de Urgenta, Alba Iulia, Romania.
Contemp Clin Trials Commun. 2024 Sep 17;42:101360. doi: 10.1016/j.conctc.2024.101360. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Patients with advanced cancer experience many symptoms and needs requiring a Palliative Care Intervention (PCI). Identifying gaps between needs for PCIs and experienced delivery may improve health care, furthermore the association of gaps with quality indicators (QI). The multicentre Romanian (RO)-Swiss (CH) reality map study implemented a novel protocol based on needs concepts and culturally adapted quality indicators (QI).
An interactive mapping guide measuring unmet needs for PCIs monthly over six months, patient characteristics (cognition, EAPC basic data set, Cofactors) and QI (Inappropriate Anticancer Treatment, High Symptom Burden [IPOS, EQ5D], Repeated ER Admissions, Aggressive End-of-Life Care, and Quality of Death-and-Dying) were developed, applying swiss standards for quality assurance. A composite endpoint (QI, cofactors) was planned. Finally, local solutions responding to gaps were piloted.
From 308 patients (RO: 262, CH: 46, age 62j [mean], 74 % ECOG PS 1&2, 81 % current anticancer treatment) baseline and first follow-up data revealed main gaps (symptom management, spiritual needs, family support), country differences (e.g. illness understanding, spiritual needs) and a significant association of the number of gaps with depression. Later data become less, and data quality on QI variable, revealing gaps in research conduct competences, resources, and applicability of over-sophisticated quality assurance tools. Nevertheless, the unmet needs data promoted local initiatives, 81 patients participated in feasibility studies. Finally, the joint experience stimulated academic developments and national integration of palliative care into oncology.
Pairing motivation and enthusiasm with more modest aims, feasibility testing of all outcomes and investment in research competences may disperse gaps.
晚期癌症患者会经历多种症状和需求,需要姑息治疗干预(PCI)。识别PCI需求与实际提供之间的差距可能会改善医疗保健,此外,还需了解这些差距与质量指标(QI)之间的关联。罗马尼亚(RO)-瑞士(CH)多中心现实地图研究实施了一种基于需求概念和文化适应性质量指标(QI)的新方案。
制定了一份交互式地图指南,在六个月内每月测量PCI未满足的需求、患者特征(认知、EAPC基本数据集、辅助因素)和QI(不适当的抗癌治疗、高症状负担[IPOS、EQ5D]、反复急诊入院、积极的临终关怀以及死亡和临终质量),采用瑞士质量保证标准。计划了一个综合终点(QI、辅助因素)。最后,对针对差距的当地解决方案进行了试点。
从308名患者(RO:262名,CH:46名,平均年龄62岁,74%的ECOG PS为1&2,81%正在接受抗癌治疗)的基线和首次随访数据中发现了主要差距(症状管理、精神需求、家庭支持)、国家差异(如对疾病的理解、精神需求)以及差距数量与抑郁症之间的显著关联。后期数据减少,QI变量的数据质量显示在研究实施能力、资源以及过于复杂的质量保证工具的适用性方面存在差距。尽管如此,未满足需求的数据推动了当地的倡议,81名患者参与了可行性研究。最后,共同的经验促进了学术发展以及姑息治疗在肿瘤学中的全国整合。
将积极性和热情与更适度的目标相结合、对所有结果进行可行性测试以及对研究能力进行投入可能会缩小差距。