Bustamante Perez Luz Adriana, Romo Lucia, Zerhouni Oulmann
Laboratoire EA 4430-Clinique Psychanalyse Developpement, Department of Psychology, University of Paris Nanterre, Nanterre, France.
Inserm-Le Centre de Recherche en Epidémiologie et Santé des Populations 1018 UPS, Paris, France.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2024 Oct 2;12:e51025. doi: 10.2196/51025.
Mobile health apps can facilitate access to effective treatment and therapeutic information services. However, the real-world effectiveness of mobile apps for smoking cessation and their potential impact in everyday settings remain unclear.
In an ecological context, this study aimed to estimate the engagement rate of a mobile app-based smoking cessation preparation program and its potential impact on users' willingness, ability, and readiness to quit smoking.
A total of 2331 "organic users" (ie, users who discover and install a mobile app on their own, without any prompts) chose 1 of 2 program versions of the mobile app (Kwit): the basic version or the premium version. Both versions were identical in design, with 4 more evidence-based content items and strategies in the premium version. Outcomes were analyzed based on automated data registered in the app (engagement rate, motivation to quit, motivation type, motivation levels, and satisfaction level). Mann-Whitney and χ tests were used to compare the results of both groups.
As expected, in the ecological context, a high dropout rate was observed at different moments. A significant difference was observed between the 2 versions (n=2331; χ=5.4; P=.02), with a proportionally higher engagement rate in the premium version (premium=4.7% vs basic=2%). Likewise, differences were also observed between the 2 groups in terms of reasons to quit (n=2331; χ=19; P≤.001; V=0.08), motivation type (n=2331; χ=14.7; P=.04), and motivation level. Users of the app's premium version more frequently reported "well-being" (23.3% vs 17.9%) and "planning a pregnancy" (7.4% vs 4.4%) as their primary reasons for quitting smoking compared to those with the basic version. Moreover, they reported being more likely to be driven in the smoking cessation process by intrinsic motivation (premium=28% vs basic=20.4%), as well as feeling significantly more willing (z score=156,055; P≤.001; Cohen d=0.15), able (z score=172,905; P=.04; Cohen d=0.09), and ready (z score=166,390; P=.005; Cohen d=0.12) to stop smoking than users who had the basic version before completion of the preparation program. Among participants who finished each version of the program (premium: 9/189, 4.8%; basic: 47/2142, 2.19%), significant improvements in motivation levels were observed in both groups, although in different areas for each group (willingness levels for the premium group and ability for the basic group).
These results suggest that even in ecological contexts where engagement rates are meager, the Kwit preparation program can address ambivalence by increasing willingness to change, self-confidence, and readiness to quit among its users, especially those who feel less able to do so. Further development and evaluations are needed to better understand determinants for regular mobile health apps.
移动健康应用程序有助于提供有效的治疗和治疗信息服务。然而,移动应用程序在戒烟方面的实际效果及其在日常环境中的潜在影响仍不明确。
在生态环境中,本研究旨在评估基于移动应用程序的戒烟准备计划的参与率及其对用户戒烟意愿、能力和准备情况的潜在影响。
共有2331名“有机用户”(即自行发现并安装移动应用程序,无任何提示的用户)选择了移动应用程序(Kwit)的2个程序版本之一:基本版本或高级版本。两个版本在设计上相同,高级版本多了4项基于证据的内容和策略。根据应用程序中自动记录的数据(参与率、戒烟动机、动机类型、动机水平和满意度)对结果进行分析。使用曼-惠特尼检验和χ检验比较两组结果。
正如预期的那样,在生态环境中,在不同阶段观察到较高的退出率。两个版本之间存在显著差异(n = 2331;χ = 5.4;P = 0.02),高级版本的参与率相对较高(高级版本 = 4.7%,基本版本 = 2%)。同样,两组在戒烟原因(n = 2331;χ = 19;P≤0.001;V = 0.08)、动机类型(n = 2331;χ = 14.7;P = 0.04)和动机水平方面也存在差异。与基本版本的用户相比,应用程序高级版本的用户更频繁地报告“幸福感”(23.3% 对 17.9%)和“计划怀孕”(7.4% 对 4.4%)作为他们戒烟的主要原因。此外,他们报告在戒烟过程中更有可能受到内在动机的驱动(高级版本 = 28%,基本版本 = 20.4%),并且在完成准备计划之前,与使用基本版本的用户相比,他们明显更愿意(z分数 = 156,055;P≤0.001;科恩d = 0.15)、更有能力(z分数 = 172,905;P = 0.04;科恩d = 0.09)和更准备好(z分数 = 166,390;P = 0.005;科恩d = 0.12)戒烟。在完成每个版本计划的参与者中(高级版本:9/189,4.8%;基本版本:47/2142,2.19%),两组的动机水平均有显著提高,尽管每组的提高领域不同(高级组的意愿水平和基本组的能力)。
这些结果表明,即使在参与率较低的生态环境中,Kwit准备计划也可以通过提高用户的改变意愿、自信心和戒烟准备情况来解决矛盾心理,尤其是那些觉得自己能力较弱的用户。需要进一步的开发和评估,以更好地了解常规移动健康应用程序的决定因素。