What Has the Sudden Unexpected Infant Death and Sudden Death in the Young Case Registry Learned About Consenting Families for DNA Banking and/or Genomic Research?

Since 2015, the Sudden Unexpected Infant Death (SUID) and Sudden Death in the Young (SDY) Case Registry has characterized sudden and unexpected deaths among young people (0-20 years). Families may provide informed consent to save biospecimens for banking and/or genomic research. We reviewed all consent-eligible cases to describe the frequency, time from death to consent, type (paper, phone, or electronic), and staffing method (Medical Examiner Office-based bereavement counselor vs outsourced genetic counselor). Of 5438 cases from January 2015 to January 2022, 3498 (64%) were eligible for consent and 391 (11%) were successfully consented. Half (54%) were obtained within 60 days of the death, 39% within 48 hours. Most were paper based (73%); 23% were obtained by phone, and 4% electronically. Consent rates varied by site from 3% to 66%. Higher consent rates were achieved within a Medical Examiner Office by a social worker or death investigator. Only 3% of consents attempted by a contracted genetic counselor were successful. Identified barriers include lack of available contact information, inability to reach family using the collected information, and lack of response when contacted. Consent rates were highest shortly after death when families were contacted by the Medical Examiner Office as part of bereavement outreach.