Ekizoglu Oguzhan, Er Ali, Bozdag Mustafa, Grabherr Silke
Department of Forensic Medicine, Tepecik Training and Research Hospital, Izmir, Turkey.
University Centre of Legal Medicine Lausanne-Geneva, Geneva University Hospital and University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
Int J Legal Med. 2025 Jan;139(1):237-243. doi: 10.1007/s00414-024-03342-9. Epub 2024 Oct 5.
Forensic age estimation is crucial in various legal and civil contexts, particularly in regions experiencing significant migration and inadequate birth registration systems. This study evaluates the applicability of the Vieth staging system for forensic age estimation in the living using MRI of the distal radial epiphysis. A retrospective analysis was conducted on 620 left wrist MRI scans from individuals aged 9.92 to 29.58 years. The study demonstrated high intra- and inter-observer agreement values (κ = 0.974 and κ = 0.961), confirming the method's reliability. Spearman's rank correlation analysis showed significant positive correlations between age and ossification stage for both sexes. The minimum ages observed for males were 9.92 years at stage 2, 15.00 years at stage 3, 15.00 years at stage 4, 17.00 years at stage 5, and 20.00 years at stage 6. For females, the minimum ages were 10.08 years at stage 2, 12.33 years at stage 3, 14.25 years at stage 4, 16.33 years at stage 5, and 18.42 years at stage 6. The study supports the applicability of the Vieth methodology for forensic age estimation in the living and suggests that MRI could be a non-invasive and potentially effective tool for determining critical age thresholds in forensic contexts. Further research is recommended to refine these methods and explore their applicability across different populations.
法医年龄估计在各种法律和民事背景下至关重要,特别是在经历大量移民和出生登记系统不完善的地区。本研究评估了使用桡骨远端骨骺的MRI的Vieth分期系统在活体法医年龄估计中的适用性。对620例年龄在9.92至29.58岁之间的个体的左手腕MRI扫描进行了回顾性分析。研究显示观察者内和观察者间的一致性值较高(κ = 0.974和κ = 0.961),证实了该方法的可靠性。Spearman等级相关分析显示,两性的年龄与骨化阶段之间均存在显著正相关。男性在第2阶段的最小年龄为9.92岁,第3阶段为15.00岁,第4阶段为15.00岁,第5阶段为17.00岁,第6阶段为20.00岁。女性在第2阶段的最小年龄为10.08岁,第3阶段为12.33岁,第4阶段为14.25岁,第5阶段为16.33岁,第6阶段为18.42岁。该研究支持Vieth方法在活体法医年龄估计中的适用性,并表明MRI可能是在法医背景下确定关键年龄阈值的一种非侵入性且潜在有效的工具。建议进一步研究以完善这些方法并探索其在不同人群中的适用性。