Becker Julia C, Hartwich Lea, Radke Helena R M
University of Osnabrueck, Osnabrück, Germany.
James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland, Australia.
Br J Soc Psychol. 2025 Apr;64(2):e12809. doi: 10.1111/bjso.12809. Epub 2024 Oct 7.
Based on the Elaborated Social Identity Model of Crowd Behaviour, we tested in two experiments whether a forceful display of police power increases perceptions of illegitimacy of the police and the formation of resistance among protestors. In the high power condition, the police were dressed in riot gear (with helmets, armed with shields and batons). In the low power condition, the police were dressed in regular uniforms. In both studies, people participated in a demonstration against right-wing populism using a virtual reality setting and were either stopped by the police in riot gear or by the police in regular uniforms. The results of Study 1 (N = 155) show that the police in riot gear were evaluated as more illegitimate compared to the police in normal clothing. The results of Study 2 (N = 97) replicated this finding and illustrated that police in riot gear (compared to regular uniforms) increased protestors' intentions to engage in direct resistance against the police. This effect was mediated by perceptions of illegitimacy and anger directed at the police. Furthermore, weakly identified protestors were particularly affected by the display of power and were more likely to engage in anti-police resistance and collective action. Implications are discussed.
基于群体行为的精细社会认同模型,我们在两项实验中测试了强力展示警察权力是否会增加对警察非法性的认知以及抗议者中抵抗情绪的形成。在高权力条件下,警察身着防暴装备(戴着头盔,手持盾牌和警棍)。在低权力条件下,警察身着常规制服。在两项研究中,人们使用虚拟现实场景参与一场反对右翼民粹主义的示威活动,他们要么被身着防暴装备的警察拦下,要么被身着常规制服的警察拦下。研究1(N = 155)的结果表明,与身着普通服装的警察相比,身着防暴装备的警察被认为更不合法。研究2(N = 97)的结果重复了这一发现,并表明身着防暴装备的警察(与常规制服相比)增加了抗议者对警察进行直接抵抗的意图。这种效应是由对警察非法性的认知和愤怒介导的。此外,认同感较弱的抗议者尤其受到权力展示的影响,更有可能参与反警察抵抗和集体行动。我们对研究结果的影响进行了讨论。