SIT Teaching and Learning Academy (STLA), Singapore Institute of Technology, Singapore, Singapore.
Health and Social Sciences, Singapore Institute of Technology, Singapore, Singapore.
J Med Internet Res. 2024 Oct 7;26:e49505. doi: 10.2196/49505.
Health care students often endure numerous stressors throughout their undergraduate education that can have lasting negative effects on their mental well-being. Positive Intelligence (PQ) is a digital mental fitness program designed to enhance self-mastery and help individuals reach their potential by strengthening various "mental muscles."
This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of a 6-week app-delivered PQ program in reducing perceived stress, increasing self-compassion, and decreasing rumination tendencies among health care undergraduates. We hypothesized that students would show reductions in perceived stress, increases in self-compassion, and decreases in rumination tendencies by the end of the PQ program, compared with their preprogram scores. We adopted an exploratory approach for the 5-month follow-up due to the limited research consensus on the sustained effects of app-based programs over varying periods.
The PQ program includes weekly hour-long videos, weekly group meetings, and daily 15-minute app-guided practices. Participants were first-year students from the occupational therapy program at a university in Singapore. Participants completed surveys measuring self-compassion, perceived stress, and rumination levels before and after the PQ program, and again at a 5-month follow-up. Data were analyzed using repeated measures ANOVA to assess differences across the pretest, immediate posttest, and follow-up posttest.
Out of 87 students enrolled in the study, the final sample consisted of 64 students (n=47, 73%, female; mean age 23 years, SD 5.06 years) with complete data. At the end of the 6 weeks, students exhibited significant increases in self-compassion (before the intervention: mean 3.07, SD 0.35; after the intervention: mean 3.34, SD 0.35; P<.001) and reductions in rumination tendencies (before the intervention: mean 3.57, SD 0.40; after the intervention: mean 3.27, SD 0.34; P<.001). However, no significant change in perceived stress levels was observed (before the intervention: 2.99, SD 0.14; after the intervention: mean 2.97, SD 0.16; P=.50). These effects were not influenced by the daily app-based practice of PQ exercises, and there were no sustained effects on self-compassion (mean 3.17, SD 0.27; P=.09) or rumination tendencies (mean 3.42, SD 0.38; P=.06) at the 5-month follow-up. Additionally, there was a significant increase in perceived stress at follow-up (mean 3.17, SD 0.21; P<.001) compared with pre- and postintervention levels.
The PQ program did not directly alter stress perceptions but may have reframed students' automatic negative thought processes, increased their awareness of self-sabotaging behaviors, and enhanced their self-compassion while reducing ruminative thinking. These findings highlight the importance of self-awareness for students' well-being. Students can benefit from practices such as mindfulness and peer discussions to enhance self-compassion and reduce rumination. Educators trained in the PQ program can foster a supportive environment that encourages self-compassion, challenges negative self-talk, and helps students manage stress.
医学生在本科教育过程中经常承受许多压力源,这些压力源可能会对他们的心理健康产生持久的负面影响。积极智能(Positive Intelligence,PQ)是一种数字心理健康训练计划,旨在通过加强各种“心理肌肉”来增强自我掌控力,帮助个人发挥潜力。
本研究旨在评估为期 6 周的应用程序提供的 PQ 计划在降低医学生感知压力、提高自我同情和减少沉思倾向方面的有效性。我们假设与干预前的分数相比,学生在 PQ 计划结束时会表现出感知压力的降低、自我同情的增加和沉思倾向的减少。由于在不同时间段基于应用程序的程序的持续效果方面共识有限,因此我们对 5 个月的随访采用了探索性方法。
PQ 计划包括每周一小时的视频、每周一次的小组会议和每天 15 分钟的应用程序指导练习。参与者为新加坡一所大学作业治疗项目的一年级学生。参与者在 PQ 计划之前、之后以及 5 个月的随访中完成了衡量自我同情、感知压力和沉思水平的调查。使用重复测量方差分析来评估在预测试、即时后测试和随访后测试之间的差异。
在注册的 87 名学生中,最终样本包括 64 名学生(n=47,73%,女性;平均年龄 23 岁,标准差 5.06 岁),数据完整。在 6 周结束时,学生表现出明显的自我同情增加(干预前:平均 3.07,标准差 0.35;干预后:平均 3.34,标准差 0.35;P<.001)和沉思倾向减少(干预前:平均 3.57,标准差 0.40;干预后:平均 3.27,标准差 0.34;P<.001)。然而,感知压力水平没有显著变化(干预前:2.99,标准差 0.14;干预后:平均 2.97,标准差 0.16;P=.50)。这些效果不受每天基于应用程序的 PQ 练习的影响,在 5 个月的随访中,自我同情(平均 3.17,标准差 0.27;P=.09)或沉思倾向(平均 3.42,标准差 0.38;P=.06)没有持续效果。此外,与干预前和干预后相比,随访时感知压力明显增加(平均 3.17,标准差 0.21;P<.001)。
PQ 计划并未直接改变压力感知,但可能重新构建了学生的自动负面思维过程,提高了他们对自我破坏行为的认识,并增强了自我同情,同时减少了沉思性思维。这些发现强调了自我意识对学生幸福感的重要性。学生可以从正念和同伴讨论等实践中受益,以增强自我同情和减少沉思。接受 PQ 计划培训的教育者可以营造一个支持性的环境,鼓励自我同情、挑战消极的自我对话,并帮助学生管理压力。