Balel Yunus
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Faculty of Dentistry, Sivas Cumhuriyet University, Sivas 58000, Turkiye.
J Stomatol Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2024 Oct 5;126(4):102110. doi: 10.1016/j.jormas.2024.102110.
Reliable metrics are needed to measure the impact of academic publications in order to fully understand and evaluate the contributions of articles published in the field of oral and maxillofacial surgery(OMFS). The aim was to identify and analyze the top 100 articles each year, with the highest Field-Weighted Citation Impact(FWCI) and citation counts, in the field of OMFS over the past decade, totaling 1,000 articles.
The research was conducted on April 20, 2024, using the Scopus database. It identified the top 100 articles each year with the highest FWCI from the top six journals with the highest metric scores in OMFS, totaling 1,000 articles. The citation counts of these publications in Google Scholar were also recorded. The predictor variable was the articles. The primary outcome variable was the FWCI value, while the secondary outcome variable was the number of citations. The covariates were the journals in which the articles were published, the publication year, the type of document, the type of access policy, and the subject of the research.
There was a weak positive correlation between FWCI and citation count(rho = 0.083, P = .009). All covariates significantly affected FWCI(P < .005), while all but access policy significantly affected citation count(P = .167). The highest average FWCI(6.31 ± 5.51) was observed in the Journal of Stomatology, Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery(JSOMS), and the highest citation count was found in the Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery(JOMS)(61.5 ± 126.4). Orthognathic Surgery and Dentofacial Deformities were the scientific fields with the most publications(14 %). COVID-19 and Artificial Intelligence had the highest FWCI(8.65 ± 10.98 and 7.68 ± 6.42, respectively). MRONJ had the highest average citation count(88.6 ± 254).
This study demonstrates that using both FWCI and citation count metrics can more accurately assess the impact of academic publications in the field of OMFS. These findings can serve as a guide for future research and contribute to strategic decisions aimed at improving clinical practices and patient care.
为全面理解和评估口腔颌面外科(OMFS)领域发表文章的贡献,需要可靠的指标来衡量学术出版物的影响力。目的是识别和分析过去十年中OMFS领域每年Field-Weighted Citation Impact(FWCI)和被引频次最高的前100篇文章,共计1000篇文章。
2024年4月20日利用Scopus数据库进行研究。从OMFS领域指标得分最高的前六种期刊中识别出每年FWCI最高的前100篇文章,共计1000篇文章。还记录了这些出版物在谷歌学术中的被引频次。预测变量是文章。主要结局变量是FWCI值,次要结局变量是被引频次。协变量包括文章发表的期刊、发表年份、文献类型、获取政策类型和研究主题。
FWCI与被引频次之间存在弱正相关(rho = 0.083,P = 0.009)。所有协变量均对FWCI有显著影响(P < 0.005),而除获取政策外的所有协变量均对被引频次有显著影响(P = 0.167)。在《口腔医学、口腔颌面外科杂志》(JSOMS)中观察到最高平均FWCI(6.31 ± 5.51),在《口腔颌面外科杂志》(JOMS)中被引频次最高(61.5 ± 126.4)。正颌外科和牙颌面畸形是发表文章最多的科学领域(14%)。COVID-19和人工智能的FWCI最高(分别为8.65 ± 10.98和7.68 ± 6.42)。MRONJ的平均被引频次最高(88.6 ± 254)。
本研究表明,同时使用FWCI和被引频次指标可以更准确地评估OMFS领域学术出版物的影响力。这些发现可为未来研究提供指导,并有助于做出旨在改善临床实践和患者护理的战略决策。