Li Feng, Hu ChangHao, Luo Xu
School of Nursing, Zunyi Medical University, Zunyi, China.
Department of Anesthesiology, Nanfang Hospital, Southern Medical University, Guangzhou, China.
Updates Surg. 2025 Jun 28. doi: 10.1007/s13304-025-02296-w.
BACKGROUND: With the advent of big data, artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly emerging as a promising avenue for pain management research. Integrating big data analytics, machine learning, and intelligent algorithms within AI can facilitate several significant advancements in healthcare. These include the ability to provide clinical diagnoses of pain, risk prediction, and the development of precision medicine. The number of articles on the application of AI to pain management is on the rise. However, there needs to be more information regarding the quality of the research output in this area, as well as the current hotspots and trends in research. At the same time, no bibliometric metrics have been identified that assess scientific progress in this area. In order to gain an understanding of the current status and potential future directions in the application of AI within the field of pain management, it is first necessary to undertake a visual and analytical study of the relevant research. OBJECTIVES: A bibliometric and visual analysis was conducted to identify research hotspots and trends in the application of AI in pain management over the past 30 years. METHODS: The data information source was the SCI-EXPANDED subset database of the WOS database. A manual search was conducted of all articles and reviews from the database's inception to June 29, 2024. The search was limited to English language sources. A bibliometric analysis was conducted using VOSviewer, CiteSpace, and Bibliometrix (an R-Tool of R-Studio). The analysis encompassed a range of aspects related to the global publication status of papers in the field, including countries and regions, institutions, authors, journals, keywords, and co-cited references. RESULTS: A total of 970 published papers were obtained for this study. The articles were published in 496 journals by 5679 authors affiliated with 2030 academic institutions in 84 countries or regions. From 2014 to 2024, there was a gradual increase in the number of papers published within this field, with 97% of the total published papers. The United States and China contribute the most to this growth. The most prominent research institutions are Harvard University, the University of California system, and Harvard Medical School. At the author level, Mork, Paul Jarle, Bach, and Kerstin of the Norwegian University of Science & Technology (NTNU) were identified as the authors with the highest research output. Breiman, L. of the University of California, Berkeley, emerged as the most influential author, exhibiting the highest co-citation frequency. From the perspective of journals, the Journal of Medical Internet Research, Scientific Reports, PAIN, PLOS ONE, and SPINE are the primary core journals in the field. They have a high number of published papers and co-citation frequency. Furthermore, of the 46,170 co-cited references, Loetsch J's "Machine learning in pain research," published in PAIN in 2018, had the highest number of co-citations, thus making it the most influential article in the study. Combining keywords and co-cited references for analysis leads to the conclusion that using AI for accurate clinical monitoring and risk prediction, clinical diagnosis and classification, and providing personalized treatment plans and care measures for pain has become a current research hotspot and a future trend. Machine learning, deep learning, artificial neural networks, and clinical decision support systems in artificial intelligence are frequently mentioned and commonly used to build predictive models. These are also hot research topics and trends in the field. CONCLUSIONS: The field of research on using AI for pain management is experiencing unprecedented growth and development. This study offers a novel perspective on applying AI to pain management, which may inform researchers' selection of potential journals and institutions to collaborate with. Furthermore, this study furnishes researchers with the requisite data to comprehend the present state of research, research focal points, and research tendencies in this field, thereby facilitating the implementation of AI in pain management.
背景:随着大数据时代的到来,人工智能(AI)正迅速成为疼痛管理研究的一个有前景的途径。将大数据分析、机器学习和智能算法整合到人工智能中,可以推动医疗保健领域的多项重大进展。这些进展包括提供疼痛的临床诊断、风险预测以及精准医学的发展。关于人工智能在疼痛管理中的应用的文章数量正在增加。然而,关于该领域研究成果的质量以及当前的研究热点和趋势,仍需要更多信息。同时,尚未发现评估该领域科学进展的文献计量指标。为了了解人工智能在疼痛管理领域应用的现状和未来潜在方向,首先有必要对相关研究进行可视化和分析研究。 目的:进行文献计量和可视化分析,以确定过去30年人工智能在疼痛管理应用中的研究热点和趋势。 方法:数据信息源为Web of Science(WOS)数据库的SCI-EXPANDED子集数据库。对该数据库自创建至2024年6月29日的所有文章和综述进行手动搜索。搜索仅限于英文来源。使用VOSviewer、CiteSpace和Bibliometrix(R-Studio的R工具)进行文献计量分析。分析涵盖了该领域论文全球发表状况的一系列方面,包括国家和地区、机构、作者、期刊、关键词和共被引参考文献。 结果:本研究共获得970篇已发表论文。这些文章由来自84个国家或地区的2030个学术机构的5679名作者发表在496种期刊上。2014年至2024年,该领域发表的论文数量逐渐增加,占总发表论文的97%。美国和中国对这一增长贡献最大。最突出的研究机构是哈佛大学、加利福尼亚大学系统和哈佛医学院。在作者层面,挪威科技大学(NTNU)的莫尔克、保罗·雅勒、巴赫和克斯廷被确定为研究产出最高的作者。加利福尼亚大学伯克利分校的布雷曼·L.成为最具影响力的作者,共被引频率最高。从期刊角度来看,《医学互联网研究杂志》《科学报告》《疼痛》《公共科学图书馆·综合》和《脊柱》是该领域的主要核心期刊。它们发表的论文数量多且共被引频率高。此外,在46170条共被引参考文献中,洛埃茨奇·J.于2018年发表在《疼痛》杂志上的“疼痛研究中的机器学习”共被引次数最多,因此成为该研究中最具影响力的文章。结合关键词和共被引参考文献进行分析得出结论,使用人工智能进行准确的临床监测和风险预测、临床诊断和分类,以及为疼痛提供个性化治疗方案和护理措施已成为当前的研究热点和未来趋势。人工智能中的机器学习、深度学习、人工神经网络和临床决策支持系统经常被提及并普遍用于构建预测模型。这些也是该领域热门的研究主题和趋势。 结论:利用人工智能进行疼痛管理的研究领域正在经历前所未有的增长和发展。本研究为将人工智能应用于疼痛管理提供了新的视角,这可能为研究人员选择潜在的合作期刊和机构提供参考。此外,本研究为研究人员提供了必要的数据,以了解该领域的研究现状、研究重点和研究趋势,从而促进人工智能在疼痛管理中的应用。
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-5-20
Health Technol Assess. 2006-9
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2021-4-19
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020-1-9
Health Technol Assess. 2001
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2018-1-16
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2016-4
Front Pharmacol. 2025-2-3
J Pain Symptom Manage. 2024-12
Curr Pain Headache Rep. 2024-10